Mortgage Aid Targeted Most-Delinquent Borrowers First, Leaving Others Waiting
July 30: This post has been updated.
A survey of the biggest mortgage servicers participating in the administration's foreclosure prevention program shows that most have focused their efforts on the most delinquent borrowers first. This helps explain why many troubled borrowers who are not yet in default – but should be eligible for the program – say they've found it hard to get their servicers to modify their loan.
July 4 marks the fourth month of the Obama administration's $75 billion effort. So far, more than 200,000 loan modifications have been offered, the Treasury Department said recently. Officials have said the plan should help as many as 4 million homeowners, but some frustrated borrowers have told us that the program seems to be off to a slow start.
In particular, a number of homeowners who've managed to keep up with their payments have told us they've gotten nowhere with their loan servicers – in some cases, they've even been told to stop payments if they want help. Credit counselors generally say that homeowners should never default on purpose, even to receive extra aid.
We did the survey of the largest servicers in the program to see how they are implementing the program. You can see the results here.
Under the program – called Making Home Affordable (MHA)– the government offers incentive payments to participating loan servicers that lower homeowners' monthly mortgage payments to 31 percent of their income.
In practice, modifying millions of mortgages requires not only a massive effort to hire and train staff but also a “sea change” in mindset for servicers, who have traditionally focused on collecting monthly payments and foreclosing when necessary, according to Kurt Eggert, a law professor and expert in mortgage servicing at Chapman University.
| Servicer | Implementation Plan |
Total MHA Trial Modifications To Date |
Total Loan Portfolio, as of Mar. 31, 2009 |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Bank of America / Countrywide ![]() |
|
45,000, as of June 22 | $2,112,800,000,000 |
Wells Fargo![]() |
No comment | 52,000 as of July 16 | $1,767,808,000,000 |
Chase Financial![]() |
|
87,100, as of June 30 | $1,477,630,000,000 |
CitiMortgage![]() |
Working with all eligible homeowners, regardless of delinquency status | No comment | $791,936,000,000 |
GMAC Mortgage![]() |
Started by targeting borrowers who are most delinquent, but currently helping all eligible borrowers, regardless of delinquency status. | No comment | $390,657,000,000 |
Sources: Bank of America spokesman Rick Simon, Wells Fargo spokesman Jason Menke, Chase Financial spokesman Tom Kelly, CitiMortgage spokesman Mark Rodgers, and GMAC Mortgage Communications Manager Jane Conroy.
Portfolio data from National Mortgage News
Update: Wells Fargo said it had completed 52,000 loan modifications through the government's program as of July 16.
Foreclosure Crisis: Banks and Government Fail Homeowners
Banks and the government have fallen short in helping homeowners in danger of foreclosure.
The Story So Far
Systemic failures at the country’s banks and mortgage servicers have exacerbated the most severe foreclosure crisis since the Great Depression, and government efforts to limit the damage have fallen short. ProPublica created an unrivaled database of homeowners who have faced foreclosure, opened a Facebook page to encourage homeowners to share their stories, wrote profiles of some of them, and incorporated their experiences into our reporting. We also provided a comprehensive rundown of the numbers behind the crisis.
Latest Stories in this Project
- Where Are the Foreclosure Deal Millions Going in Your State?
- Billion Dollar Bait & Switch: States Divert Foreclosure Deal Funds
- 10 Questions – And Answers – To Help You Understand the Foreclosure Crisis
- Big Banks Slack on Maintaining Foreclosed Homes in Minority Areas, Complaint Charges
- Excerpt: At Goldman Sachs Servicer, 'Total Disaster'
Get Updates
Our Hottest Stories
- Donations to Scott Walker Flagged as Potential Fraud
- In Race For Better Cell Service, Men Who Climb Towers Pay With Their Lives
- Billion Dollar Bait & Switch: States Divert Foreclosure Deal Funds
- Pardon Attorney Torpedoes Plea for Presidential Mercy
- Patient Died at New York VA Hospital After Alarm Was Ignored
- Introducing the ProPublica Patient Harm Community on Facebook
- Got Student Loans? Share Your Documents With Us
- Built for a Simpler Era, OSHA Struggles When Tower Climbers Die
- Remember Stuxnet? Why the U.S. is Still Vulnerable
- Congressional Leader Calls for Investigation of the Pardon Office
- Donations to Scott Walker Flagged as Potential Fraud
- Pardon Attorney Torpedoes Plea for Presidential Mercy
- In Race For Better Cell Service, Men Who Climb Towers Pay With Their Lives
- Air Force Pilots Balk at Flying the World’s Most Expensive Fighter Jet
- Watchdog Group Calls for Probe of Lobbyists Behind Congressional Trip to Taiwan
- Patient Died at New York VA Hospital After Alarm Was Ignored
- Billion Dollar Bait & Switch: States Divert Foreclosure Deal Funds
- N.Y. Congressman Will Reimburse Costs for $22,000 Taiwan trip
- Remember Stuxnet? Why the U.S. is Still Vulnerable
- Happy Graduation! Here's The Best, Most Depressing Journalism on Student Debt












