ProPublica

Journalism in the Public Interest

Cancel

Pennsylvania’s Gas Wells Booming—But So Are Spills

A gas drilling site on the Marcellus Shale is seen in Hickory, Pa., on Feb. 24, 2009. (Jason Cohn/Reuters)As more gas wells are drilled in Pennsylvania's Marcellus Shale, more cases of toxic spills are being reported. Earlier this month, Pennsylvania's environmental officials fined Pennsylvania-based Atlas Resources after a series of violations at 13 wells, including spills of fracturing fluids and other contaminants onto the ground around the sites. And just last week the agency fined M.R. Dirt, a company that removes waste from drilling sites, $6,000 for spilling more than seven tons of drilling dirt along a public road.

The reports come on the heels of a string of other incidents that have killed fish in one of the state's most prized recreational lakes and released toxic chemicals into the environment.

The Atlas spills are significant because they are among the latest and because they happened repeatedly during the routine transfer of fluids. Pennsylvania's Department of Environmental Protection fined Atlas Resources $85,000 for the offenses, which took place between May and December of 2009. Many of the spills were discovered by DEP inspectors.

The violations (PDF) cited by the DEP include spills of fluids from the hydraulic fracturing process at seven sites, and failure to report a spill at one of those sites. One spill was the result of a faulty pit liner, which is supposed to insulate the ground from hydraulic fracturing fluids after they are pumped out of a well.

Atlas Resources controls more than half a million acres within the Marcellus Shale, the massive gas deposit that stretches from Tennessee to New York. The company, whose total revenue was $787.4 million in 2008, issued a statement acknowledging that it had entered a voluntary settlement with the DEP and saying that each of the incidents had been corrected. An Atlas spokesman declined a request to answer additional questions about the violations, or about the company's operations in Pennsylvania.

"If you look at this series of violations -- it's not only that there are multiple violations," said DEP spokeswoman Helen Humphreys, pointing to the fact that the same three violations were turning up at each site. "This is a pattern, and it's a problem."

The pattern, and the problem, extend beyond Atlas.

In December the DEP fined Chesapeake and Schlumberger, two of the biggest operators in the Marcellus Shale and in gas development nationally, for spilling hydrochloric acid, which is used for hydraulic fracturing and is corrosive. Cabot Oil and Gas, a Houston-based energy company that lists T. Boone Pickens as one of its stockholders, was fined in November for a series of spills, including a fracturing fluid spill by its contractor Halliburton.

In October Pennsylvania fined (PDF) Texas-based Range Resources $23,500 for spilling nearly 5,000 gallons of wastewater, including hydraulic fracturing fluids, into a tributary of Cross Creek Lake, a protected watershed near Pittsburgh that contains some of the state's most robust fish populations.

A DEP report (PDF) on that spill said, "The creek was impacted by sediments all the way down to the lake and there was also evidence of a fish kill as invertebrates and fish were observed lying dead in the creek.”

The Range Resources spill occurred on May 26, when the company was pumping fluids from the hydraulic fracturing of three wells through a six-inch pipe to a DEP-approved impoundment. Along the way, two screws along the pipe came loose, according to the Range Resources report on the incident, allowing thousands of gallons to spill onto the ground before the company was able to shut it down.

Range Resources spokesman Matt Pitzarella said the loosened screws were a result of vandalism and that the company responded by increasing security at its sites. The fish killed in Cross Creek amounted to less than a pound of minnows, he said.

Just three weeks before the fines were announced, Range was penalized by the DEP for another accident -- this time for spilling more than 10,000 gallons of flowback water, which again resulted in a fish kill and a substantial cleanup effort. A DEP spokesman said he could not comment on that spill, because a settlement is still being decided.

"We find both of these to be unfortunate and unacceptable," said Pitzarella, who said that neither spill had any negative impacts on health or property.

Unlike previous spills -- including the recent Atlas spills -- the DEP has not issued press releases for either of the Range Resources spills, and a spokesman has not explained why.

I bet you don’t know what’s in those fracking compounds and I bet you never find out. Seems like the wild wild West has moved East.

Atlas Resources’ total revenue in 2008 was $787.4 million. How much impact is an $85,000 fine going to have on Atlas? They will simply write it off as a cost of doing business. In order for these fines to have any impact they would have to be large enough to be a true deterrent. Further, a company that repeatedly violates the rules should no longer be allowed to drill in the state. Atlas had piled up 13 violations. Unless and until the regulations have some teeth, they will be utterly useless: it will be cheaper for the companies to ignore the rules and then just pay the fines.

A handful of PA residents will get rich from the drilling, but most who live in drilling areas will not get rich. Instead they will suffer as their health, their environment, and their quality of life are destroyed by the drilling. And then they—not the gas companies—will end up paying taxes to clean up the mess left behind by the drilling.

we the people

Jan. 29, 2010, 2:50 p.m.

Pennsylvania has a budget shortfall:Solution- Pa. legislature forces DCNR (department of conservation and natural resources)to hand over 174 million dollars from the oil and gas lease fund P.L 865, No.256 act.of Dec. 15, 1955.and immediatly tranferred to the general fund.This money was used by the DCNR for conservation,recreation,flood control and acquiring more state game land.As if this is’nt disturbing enough,they then proceed to force the DCNR to Lease off and put up for bid 32,000 acres of state forest land in northern Pa.These are the last big tracts of large forest lands in Pa.where pristine native brook and brown trout streams fresh-water springs and creeks form rivers to water supplies downsteam.Theres already alot of evidence of fracking fluid contaminating water supplies elsewhere in the state,and no one knows or wants to admit to the chemicals used in the fracking process and health effects for people and wildlife.It’s all abuot the money!