ProPublica

Journalism in the Public Interest

Cancel

From Russia With PR

Commentaries published on CNBC.com and the Huffington Post were written by seemingly independent professionals but placed on behalf of the Russian government by its PR firm, Ketchum.

« Return to Story

Sort by: Oldest Newest  1 2 >

Mr. Shahislam

Sep. 16, 2013, 2:52 p.m.

The solution finding should start with…..........
It’s now due -publishing the data of state heads and Insurance underwriting, royal-gun-bomb-making business bosses that were behind 1st 9/11 event & its repeating trend in our home territory!

ibsteve2u

Sep. 16, 2013, 2:24 p.m.

@Andrew:  When one steps outside the definition of “conjecture” and into the realm of “assertion”, it is always nice to support/substantiate your “assertion” with verifiable URLs/links from reputable sources.

Andrew

Sep. 16, 2013, 1:19 p.m.

Anyone else alarmed by the number of comments that are coming from extreme right-wingers who think this article reveals a “communist” conspiracy??? Wake up people!  Nothing could be more absurd.
What it in fact reveals is a corporate PR plan involving corporate, FOR PROFIT players INSIDE RUSSIA. Not COMMUNISTS!
That, and the US CORPORATIONS WORKING TOGETHER WITH THE CORPORATIONS INSIDE RUSSIA TO MAKE A PROFIT, BUT AT THE EXPENSE OF HONESTY AND THE PUBLIC INTEREST.  THATS IT.
Get it???

ibsteve2u

Sep. 13, 2013, 2:49 p.m.

Putin is just taking a page out of Fox‘s/Murdoch’s/Aisle’s book:  Say anything you want ‘cuz your definitions of “editorial” and “journalism” don’t mention “truth”.

It really is too bad that 22 U.S.C. § 611 (et seq.)

http://www.gpo.gov/fdsys/pkg/USCODE-2009-title22/pdf/USCODE-2009-title22-chap11-subchapII.pdf

was gutted in 1995 to remove the term “political propaganda”. 

I figure both the NYT (witness this article) and all of Fox (their endless “Divide, and conquer.” lies aimed at the American people insist that they are agents operating on behalf of the PRC and/or Russia) could have been prosecuted under it.

Chris Herz

Nov. 26, 2012, 9:41 p.m.

We are all fortunate that Joseph Stalin never realized how easy it is to buy both US media and US politicians.  Putin’s Russia is only following in the footsteps of China.

HuffAndPuffPost

Nov. 24, 2012, 6:01 p.m.

Ariana is proof that screwing your way to success is still a viable option for someone otherwise untalented.

Nicolas von Schatz

Nov. 24, 2012, 2:15 p.m.

Those asslicking henchmen must be hanged together with their bastard russian commie owners.

clarence swinney

Nov. 20, 2012, 10:45 a.m.

BUSH TAX CUTS
10 years 2001-2010
total loss of revenue(borrowed)=$1901 Billion
Gifs to rich
1%=37.6%=$715.2B
5%=48.3%=$919.7B
20%=78.5%
bottom 60%=16.4%=Yuk!
John nichols in the nation.com on twinkes
“vulture capitalism ate your twinkes”

clarence swinney

Nov. 19, 2012, 6:17 p.m.

NEO-CON DESTROY DEMOCRACY
Since 1980 their Record:
Ruined our great middle class savings and loan
Closed Fairness Doctrine that has let Limbaugh types on airwaves
Closed Revenue Sharing
Initiated our involvement in 10 foreign conflicts.
Repealed Glass-Steagall allowing 5 Too Big To Fail to hold 50% of 7 000 Banks deposits
and 10 to hold 80%.
Crashed the stock market 5 times
Modernization of Commodities markets—-from investment to Casino Derivative of America.
Two very very dumb invasions of two unarmed, destitute Muslim nations.
Ruined our international reputation as a Do Good Christian nation to Big Bully Nation.
Stood by as freak marketeers ruined out Housing Industry.
Stood by as Casino Derivative of America damaged the world financial industry.
Impeached a great president for petty political gains that created a long term animosity between two parties.
Attempted to destroy the Safety Nets that hold together a great middle class.
Implemented Tax Codes that permitted a redistribution of Wealth to top 10% who now own 73% of all Net Wealth, 83% of all Financial Wealth and get 50% of all individual income.
They have taken America from top five on Equality to fourth from bottom in OECD nations.
Since 1980, their Spend and Borrow policies, mainly, were responsible for adding 15,000 Billion to A 1000B Debt in 1980.
Fought the Great GI Bill
Fought the WWII Draft
Give these Neo-Cons total control is end of Democracy to a Corpocracy.

Shahislam

Nov. 19, 2012, 2:13 p.m.

The writings on the wall sometime ago became enough clear to be noticeable globally. It would be wise to focus on what we have at our disposal today. We -the ‘not hot-tempered ones’ only are capable of helping now make betterment of Obama’s administration for the collective true benefit of North-Americans beyond bipartisan limitations of things

Shahislam

Nov. 19, 2012, 2:05 p.m.

It’s wise focus on what we have at our disposal.  We -the ‘not hot-tempered ones’ only are capable of helping now make betterment of Obama’s administration for the collective true benefit of North-Americans beyond bipartisan limitations of things.

John

Nov. 19, 2012, 11:55 a.m.

To the self-aggrandizing genius trying to call me out, I point out the Republicans for claiming to be against anything resembling the Soviet Union while instituting its most laughable and horrifying policies.

The Democrats have helped, but given the “wah, lefties are destroying the country” tenor of dozens of contentless comments, I figured mentioning that was redundant.  Good to see some people are smart enough to see that, even if you weren’t.

Obama’s an ass, but his administration didn’t give the telecommunications companies legal immunity for helping them spy on everybody in the country.  The KGB wished for that kind of power.  Even the Stazi would have stood in awe of what recent Republican “pro-freedom” administrations have accomplished.

Or does your idea of Communism stop at welfare?

curlyhammedMoesBrother

Nov. 19, 2012, 9:04 a.m.

Public Relations Firm…a euphemism for pimp.  Ariana is like Barry O, they both pander to the least common denominator among the uneducated.

Kevin

Nov. 18, 2012, 3:04 p.m.

HuffPo printing Russian propaganda? When did they not print it?...lol

Shahislam

Nov. 18, 2012, 5:53 a.m.

It proves that Media is still in the grip of unscrupulously wealthy thugs. People often die in thousands of head count in some part of the world as a result of human Brutality or Natural disaster. (e.g. Bangladesh, Srilanka, Nigeria etc.) and no outcry even in the cases of Saudi-Arabian type beheading atrocity.
And sometimes death of only 100 becomes big deal like WW3
e.g. 50 semites die in retaliation of a death of 1 single terrorist of semitic origin and all the top media get flooded with news, images and pictures in ways to brainwash ordinary folks with the impression of a exploded hell that doesn’t even in the cosmos.
Dumb practice but who cares for it in this rapid communication era?

Use of common sense is now better than the judgments of old style warlords and a few nards with knowledge based on memorized words of stinky law books of outdated old.

Jeremy

Nov. 17, 2012, 11:10 p.m.

LOL! Other commenters here actually think Putin is a communist. It’s even more laughable than the HuffPo being busted as the frauds that they are.

Gregory Kay

Nov. 17, 2012, 6:49 p.m.

No word yet on the endless streams of pro-US (either slanting from the left or right, depending on which is in power at the time) and pro-Israeli propaganda dished out on a much larger scale in the majority of our media. I don’t care if it’s MSNBC, FOX, or everything in between, I wish the media would stop trying to tell us what we should think, and just start telling us the truth for a change; just give us the facts, and we’ll make up our own minds.

pete

Nov. 17, 2012, 12:14 p.m.

Well big DUH!

How could anybody read some of the pablum hp tries to sell and not see Russian propaganda behind it?

My granddad left Czechoslovakia in the early 1900s, when he was a kid. All I know about the USSR is what he told me, and before he died at 103 in 1997 he said he was glad. He said could see the U.S. turning into the USSR faster than he expected.

Karl Marx

Nov. 17, 2012, 9:37 a.m.

DAMMIT ANARCHY NOW!  This is crazy!

Shahislam

Nov. 17, 2012, 9:06 a.m.

Huffington post just like Newyork times is a puppet for a faceless party. And the proof is in their old days 1way communication style.

Fools think everyone is fool.

Norma Rae

Nov. 17, 2012, 8:51 a.m.

HuffingtonPost is but a propaganda tool for the oligarchy so why should we be surprised?  Putin is fixing Russia’s PR problems in the United States so his buddy Obama can be more even “flexible” with this thug after the election. Nothing is hidden that shall not be revealed.  But Burnam Wood is moving in.

visions de paix

Nov. 17, 2012, 5:15 a.m.

Is anyone similarly tallying China’s op-ed strategies ?

They’ve already used BLJ to create a counter-narrative on Tibet and operate through US text books (paragraphs near the end:) http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/right-turn/post/washingtons-syria-lobbyists-hard-power-necessary-to-quell-rebellion/2012/07/06/gJQA0jBWSW_blog.html

Also, who’s following China’s shareholder influence strategy ?

Curlyhammed

Nov. 17, 2012, 3:29 a.m.

Having lived in Moscow and attending its “finest” schools, nothing has changed in that decrepit shithole.  Thugs everywhere and drunks pissing themselves in the Metro.  Plus, now we have a former KGB doink running the place with guns and threats.  Nothing is new under the sun.

Steve-0

Nov. 17, 2012, 1:55 a.m.

Golly gee whiz. Ketchum Public Relations does fake journalism for so many sketchy organizations….Like Putin’s communist Russia…IBM…and the U.S. Army.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ketchum_Inc.

Save your boring, endless outrage, right-wingers.  If you think American Spectator, Fox News, or World Nut Daily don’t run blatant PR pieces by amoral corporate spinmeisters, you’re delusional.

Dee

Nov. 17, 2012, 1:18 a.m.

Huff-Po is Irresponsible Journalism personified ... Arianna is a total Dingbat !!

Phil McKann

Nov. 17, 2012, 12:01 a.m.

Barack,
Call the office.

kimdi01

Nov. 16, 2012, 11:58 p.m.

If it came from the Huffington Post or any part of NBC then it can only be a bunch of lies.

Holycowgirl

Nov. 16, 2012, 11:55 p.m.

Fascinating, and thanks for the eye-opening look at scallywags we may have missed.
But now I’m curious about the 27 or so American newspapers which ran editorials, their papers backing Romney. Who paid them? Not all the VA local papers that just went under via Buffet. It must be the ones too big to not save that are still open for business. Was it part of the Obama back-up catch-all for a sympathy vote.  Ain’t politics something else and a half.

4moreyearsofhell

Nov. 16, 2012, 11:17 p.m.

Deadguin, let me educate you since no one else in your life seems to have bothered. Drudge links to ALL sites, not just one side like most of your ILK. You cannot be this stupid, can you?

LibsSuc

Nov. 16, 2012, 11:14 p.m.

John, it’s so rich how you tell us there’s no left or right and that both sides are bad. You then proceed to slam Republicans and tell us to leave because we aren’t licking Obama’s boot. Why don’t YOU leave and put us all out our misery you moron. Just admit what you are, another Socialist sympathizer disguised as some moderate, give us all a break.

kathy

Nov. 16, 2012, 10:46 p.m.

It figgures!!!! I am sure you dont really expect anything more form this rag!!!!

George Schwarz

Nov. 16, 2012, 10:25 p.m.

This is the tip of the iceberg on how PR firms push the media to either publish their clients’ political views or how PR firms try to get free advertising by providing “information.” When you call the PR people on it, they either lie, run and hide or deny. Here is something I send back to them when they are so obvious:

An open letter to PR firms and publicists

Here’s a perspective from a working journalist. Most press releases from PR firms are crap. They try to push something that should be an advertisement. By trying to get a freebie, in the long run, they undercut the business model that is already in enough trouble as is. In cannibalizing the system, also in the long run, they are eventually going to kill the information channel that gets the word out about whatever they are touting.

I’ve gotten into heated discussions in which PR people say a quid pro quo is unethical. Really? More unethical than some of the stuff PR firms pull?

If you’re putting out a release about a new legitimate service (for example, a new program at a hospital or something similar), and the news outlet picks up on it, don’t turn around and stab the news outlet in the back over advertising later. Example: A local PR firm that put out a news release on a new senior day care program. We picked up on it and did a story. A few weeks later, at a board meeting, one of the board members suggested including our outlet in the advertising campaign and the PR firm killed off that advertising. Now anything that firm puts out — worthy or not — is ignored. Truth is, it’s all a quid pro quo, and if the news outlet is important enough for a press release, it’s important enough for advertising.

And, in touting something, don’t send out an “alert.” Alerts from public safety agencies and similar news releases are appropriate. From PR firms, not so much.

Then, if you fax or email something, don’t follow with a phone call to ask if we got the fax or email. Maybe we’re considering your information; or perhaps ignoring it. If we’re interested, we’ll probably call for more information. Let it be. And, for God’s sakes, don’t “circle back.” That is such a stupid phrase and makes you sound like some kind of jargon jockey. Keep that stupidity in your own shop.

Similar advice goes for op-ed pieces. The first helpful thing for you to do is know the outlet. I get crap from a variety of conservative outfits that send us pieces that are 180 degrees opposite of our positions. Usually I respond with a one-word “pass,” but a week later get an email asking if we had a chance to read the piece and if we’re running it. If I’ve already passed on it, what part of the word “pass” do you not understand? And don’t tell me it’s a “both sides of the issue” thing for our editorial pages. It’s our outlet and if you want to pander the opposite of our views, we have a large corporate out-of-town-owned daily here that spews plenty of right-wing garbage. They’ll not only help spread the spew but will spin the news for you. We don’t.

And my final thought on this lovely dose of reality: Don’t call me by my first name when you send me stuff if you don’t know me. It’s disrespectful. And spell my last name right. That not only shows respect, but that you’ve done your homework. And every communication I’ve gotten from a PR firm is signed “all the best.” All the best what? How about something more neutral and businesslike? “Sincerely” or “respectfully” work fine.

If you think this is all harsh, fine. It’s a reality.

George Schwarz, publisher and editor
The Amarillo Independent

Uber

Nov. 16, 2012, 10:13 p.m.

What’s new? They’re just communists anyway, they wouldn’t notice if something about Russia was part of their daily wallow. They spend all their time trying to bring down America anyway.

Ted HAMPTON

Nov. 16, 2012, 8:38 p.m.

There is no one entity any better than the Russians in successfully tossing piles of propaganda and making it stick. Up until now,  the Russians and the KGB have been the undisputed Kings and have been for decades. Probably their most successful scam is the one that had the main stream media believing and portraying J Edgar Hoover as a pervert and a cross dresser.  Although never corroborated,  most of the public familiar with the allegations, still believe them to be true.
Sadly, the Russians have yielded the number one propagandist position to our own American born and ill informed Main Stream Media. Witness the recent re-election of one of the worst presidents in history.

Hardly News

Nov. 16, 2012, 8:13 p.m.

HuffPo = Pravda

Ralph Emerson

Nov. 16, 2012, 8:11 p.m.

If the federal government were not full of Marxists, Arianna Huffington would be answering to charges of treason.  Her efforts to turn this country into one patterned after USSR or Communist China are dispicable.  Shame we just re-elected the first Marxist President.  This country is committing national suicide right before our eyes and it is people like those at HuffPo that are working day and night to bring about the end of the USA and substitute the USSA.

AZ Schumi

Nov. 16, 2012, 7:29 p.m.

WHAT’S THE DIFFERENCE????

Piquerish

Nov. 16, 2012, 7 p.m.

Let me get this straight. Someone thinks it’s news that Huffington Post would publish communistic propaganda. Is that right…?

Mean One

Nov. 16, 2012, 6:19 p.m.

This is news? I am sure that you could include, ABC,NBC,CBS, MSNBC ,CNN, Democrat National Committee and a bunch more.

Joe Dokes

Nov. 16, 2012, 6:14 p.m.

time to do a petition to revoke Arianne’s citizenship.

Mark Talmont

Nov. 16, 2012, 5:36 p.m.

I don’t see why they need to bother with “planting” anything like this. They have RT.com and the Russia Today channel now carried by Comcast and Dish. It’s slick, weasley leftist propaganda like a video version of Kos. They do permit some financial commentary that is outside the narrow channel permitted on the U.S. news networks, but what does it say that something funded by the Russian government is consistently left wing and engaged is historical revisionism to suit the really far left (one of their shills ,Hartman, was on the other evening disposing of the Reagan administration’s irrational fears and how the Cold War was the product of…U.S. militarism and imperialism. The disturbing thing is there is a generation in college now that is not even dimly familiar with the Iron Curtain or Berlin Wall. One side built a fence to keep their people in, but you are an evil fascist if you want to defend yourself to keep people out.

Curiously a channel called Russia Today seems to be mostly about the U.S. They concern themselves with political dissidents here, not much about Russia or China though. It’s like “Brezhnev Vision”.

Rationalist

Nov. 16, 2012, 5:34 p.m.

Communist Goals
# 15 - Capture one or both of the political parties in the United States.
# 20 - Infiltrate the press
# 21 - Gain control of key positions in radio, TV, and motion pictures.

The cold war may be over but Communism is still around. Stay alert & be informed - from sources other than HuffPo

Sam

Nov. 16, 2012, 5:14 p.m.

Who is surprised ?
Communism, Maoism and Marxism are being taught as good things in our schools .
The only problem is they were run the ‘wrong leaders ” .
Todays leaders would make it great professors moronically all say .
Of course there is no mention over 200 Million were Murdered , Starved to death and enslaved , Politically ,imprisoned, worked to death not to  mentioned left as poor as third world Africans .

Shane Von Russell

Nov. 16, 2012, 5:03 p.m.

commie bastards.  I’ll see you in hell.

John

Nov. 16, 2012, 4:47 p.m.

When I was a kid, we made fun of the Soviet Union.  There were corrupt officials funneling money to their friends while the citizens starved.  They manipulated the economy to keep people powerless.  They exaggerated real enemies and invented other enemies to excuse abuses of power like bullying people taking pictures in public spaces.  They sunk money and lives into a losing war in Afghanistan.  They tortured political prisoners.

Thank goodness we had the Republicans, here, otherwise we might see things like Wall Street bailouts, the Patriot Act, indefinite detention, and voting machines that aren’t accountable.

You can pretend that there’s a left and a right, but if you grow up and open your eyes, you’ll notice that both “sides” use exactly the same tactics with exactly the same goals.  They want to exploit the rest of us, whether they’re commanders-in-chief or captains of industry.

Hint:  Who funded Lenin and Trotsky?  You can’t run an organized revolution without money, and it doesn’t grow on trees.

Or, you know, if you’re really that upset at Obama’s reelection (or the lack of a Romney election, even though the bailouts and ObamaCare were his ideas), then leave.  There are countries like Iran and Saudi Arabia that have exactly the hawkish, anti-populist governments you want to live under.

MCC

Nov. 16, 2012, 4:39 p.m.

Russia is going through the low grade civil wars all over its vast declining territory.  In order to prevent that Russia’s ‘s next move is to abolish ALL republics within Russia, including Chechnia, Ingushetia, Dagestan, Tatarstan - de facto, independent state recognized by Yeltsin, run by moderate Muslims wth hugeg minorities of Polish Catholics,  Russian Orthodox, Buddis, etc. Tatarstan, of course, will be turned into Chechnia, with any renewed attempts to gain independence.  In the meantime, Russia continues to destabilize not only Central Europe, especially Poland; after the assassination of the Polish President in Smolensk by Putin, the poliltical assassinations are being committed in the broad day light all over Poland - targeting the pro-western politicians s well as the people who wants international.  Speaking of the Western Europe; every child in Skandynavia knows that the collapse of Iceland was caused by two Russian billionaires who, through the Dutch and British banks invested billions and then, withdrew all investment money causing the total collapse of the country. At the same time, the EU willingly put a noose around its neck by letting Russia to be almost the sole provider of gas and oil.  Europe is heading for a total catastrophy that will end with Russia’s control of the whole continent. Selling and stealing of technology from the West is going on as usual.  So, it seems that Russia is winning… If one looks at Russia closely, though,  one can see the slow disintegration of the old empire just in front of one’s eyes.  Enter Moscow, the Russian capital and you will be entering a CENTRAL-ASIAN MUSLIM CITY [80% of inhabitant are muslim]; Russian army, truly a laughing stock of the world eats dog food, Air Forces and Navy are in total decline On top of that, ecological catastrophy all over Rusia, dying population is truly ‘winning combinaon’.  Russia is just another ‘empire’ crambling and NOTHING will stop it…

Rick Pango

Nov. 16, 2012, 4:34 p.m.

Russia nee Soviet Union has been funding the left since the anti-war protests of the 60’s - 70’s. Their coup de gras was the election of 0 by these aging dinosaurs and the ignorant children they’ve taught over the last 40 years. California used to be number 1 in education; now they are 57th.  They are now retiring and will soon depart for Berkeley in the sky.

Claymation Master

Nov. 16, 2012, 4:21 p.m.

To HELL with Obummer and this government!  ANARCHY NOW!

Joanne Brown

Nov. 16, 2012, 4:11 p.m.

So now we know what Obama meant when he whispered into Medyved’s ear that he would have more flexibility after the election.  Maybe the Federal pension fund would like to invest their money in mother Russia!

Mike Trane

Nov. 16, 2012, 4:07 p.m.

reply to Deadguin who wrote “Funny, I’d say the Drudge Report links to Far Right agenda propaganda”

FYI - Drudge Report has a link to the Huffington Post and many others including NY Times, MSNBC, CNN…

Commenting is not available in this section entry.

Get Updates

Stay on top of what we’re working on by subscribing to our email digest.

optional

Our Hottest Stories

  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •