Must-Read Stories:

• How a New Orleans Police Detective Missed a Key Clue in a Controversial Killing
• Feds Tell Two New Orleans Officers They’re Targets in Post-Katrina Shooting Probe

The Police Account

Ronald Mitchell, and his partner, Ray Jones, said they encountered Brumfield as they drove along Convention Center Boulevard about 2 a.m. on Sept. 3. Brumfield, they said, jumped on the hood of their police cruiser and then attempted to attack Mitchell with a pair of scissors. Fearing for his life, Mitchell fired a single shot from his weapon, a 12-gauge shotgun, which struck Brumfield. The officers say they got out of their vehicle and checked Brumfield’s vital signs; he was dead. As the crowd gathered at the convention center grew angry, they left.

Mitchell says he returned to the area later that night and said he saw a pair of “scissors with a red handle” on the ground near Brumfield’s corpse. Police didn’t collect the scissors, and photos reportedly taken by officers at the site of the shooting were lost.

NOPD veteran detective DeCynda Barnes, who investigated the matter, deemed the shooting justified, although she never looked at Brumfield’s autopsy report. The autopsy found he’d died from “a single shotgun wound to the left back.” She erroneously thought he’d been shot from the front, and hit in the “left shoulder,” police documents and her sworn testimony show.

The Family’s Account

Brumfield’s relatives, who were with him at the convention center and witnessed the incident, said Brumfield was trying to get the officers’ attention when he approached the police cruiser. His sister, Dolores Augustin, said he might have been trying to get aid for a dehydrated grandchild; his niece, Africa Brumfield, thought he was seeking help for a woman in the crowd who was screaming.  In depositions, both women said he wasn’t brandishing scissors and did not hurl himself onto the vehicle. The car drove into Brumfield repeatedly, throwing him onto the hood, according to Africa Brumfield.

Africa Brumfield and other witnesses said her uncle was flailing about on the hood of the car, trying to maintain his balance, when a gunshot went off. The family also contends the shooting happened around 9:30 p.m. on Sept. 2, 2005.

In 2008, the Brumfield family settled a wrongful death suit with the city of New Orleans for $400,000, according to the city attorney’s office.

Featured Case News