Scandal: Subprime Mortgages and Ratings Agencies

Who We Are

ProPublica is an independent, non-profit newsroom that produces investigative journalism in the public interest. We strive to foster change through exposing exploitation of the weak by the strong and the failures of those with power to vindicate the trust placed in them.

More...

Subprime Mortgages and Ratings Agencies

The subprime mortgage crisis, which has resulted in global losses of more than $7.7 trillion, is the outcome of unscrupulous lending by the mortgage industry, banks who bought those loans without doing the requisite research, deceptive credit ratings and the government's increasingly relaxed regulation of the banking industry.

Subprime loans are usually adjustable rate mortgages offered to high-risk borrowers, i.e. those with lower income or lesser credit history than "prime borrowers." Predatory mortgage brokers often offered these types of loans to people who had little understanding of what the contract entailed, or they encouraged borrowers to lie about their income in order to secure a loan.

Then the mortgage banks, instead of waiting years to see returns, bundled these loans together and sold them to banks across the country. When housing prices began to fall in late 2006 and mortgage rates were rising, the default rate on subprime mortgages skyrocketed. The financial industry, which now owned much of these loans, was left scrambling to cover the debts.

In March, the crisis claimed the investment bank Bear Stearns and the Federal Reserve provided financial backing to secure a merger with JPMorgan Chase. In June, federal prosecutors arrested two former Bear Stearns hedge fund managers for lying to investors.

Countrywide - the nation's largest mortgage lender - was also felled after mounting losses from subprime investments forced a sale to Bank of America. In June, The Wall Street Journal and Portfolio reported that Countrywide CEO Angelo Mozilo gave preferential mortgages to several people, including U.S. Senators, and three states filed lawsuits against the company for deceptive businesses practices.

Much blame has also been placed on the three leading credit-rating agencies, Moody's, Standard & Poor's and Fitch Ratings. They gave high ratings to many bundled subprime loans when in fact they were poised for disaster. And many critics claim that a conflict of interest was involved, as rating agencies are paid by the very firms that organize and sell the debt to investors. 

 

Mother Jones has compiled an excellent timeline of the mortgage crisis. 

Latest Stories

Ten Victims of a Calif. Scammer Lost Their Homes
- Orange County Register, August 19

Chasing Down the Calif. Scammer
- Orange County Register, August 19

Weak Rules Cripple Home Appraiser Oversight
- AP, August 18

FBI Probes Unusual Incentives for Home Buyers
- Wall Street Journal ($), August 18

Reps Request Ethics Probe of Countrywide Loans
- Fox News, August 14

Greenspan Blasts Fannie, Freddie Fix
- Wall Street Journal ($), August 14

Fla. Mortgage Regulator Resigns Under Fire
- AP, August 13

Mechanism for Credit Is Still Stuck
- New York Times, August 13

Bank Failures Rise but Critics Say Not Fast Enough
- Washington Post, August 13

Credit Crisis Triggers Unprecedented U.S. Response
- Washington Post, August 11

Mortgage-Market Trouble Reaches Big Credit Unions
- Wall Street Journal ($), August 11

Fla. Let Crooked Brokers Keep Working
- Miami Herald, August 11

Ex-Countrywide CEO is Under Formal SEC Investigation
- Los Angeles Times, August 8

Foreclosure Crisis Catches Renters Off Guard
- Washington Post, August 8

New York’s AG Mismanaged Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac
- Village Voice, August 7

Lawmakers Question Fannie, Freddie’s Right to Lobby
- Wall Street Journal ($), August 7

Conn. Sues Countrywide over Lending Practices
- AP, August 7

Freddie Mac Chief Defends Risk-Taking
- AP, August 7

Mortgages Made in 2007 Go Bad at Rapid Clip
- Wall Street Journal ($), August 7

Freddie Mac Responds to the New York Times
- Freddie Mac, August 5

Freddie Mac Chief Discarded Warning Signs
- New York Times, August 5

Civil Rights Groups Defend Predatory Lenders
- Mother Jones, August 4

BofA Lavishes Perks on Departing Countrywide Exec
- Los Angeles Times, August 4

Gov’t Report: Standard & Poor’s E-Mails Warned of Ratings
- Wall Street Journal ($), August 4

Recession May Have Begun in Last Quarter of 2007
- Bloomberg News, July 31

Bush Signs Housing Recovery Bill
- New York Times, July 30

Conn. AG Sues Top Three Credit Rating Agencies
- Reuters, July 30

Calif. Expands Lawsuit Against Countrywide
- AP, July 29

Lax Lending Standards Led to IndyMac’s Downfall
- New York Times, July 29

SEC Intensifies Effort to Rein in Short Selling
- Wall Street Journal ($), July 28

Worried Banks Reduce Business Loans
- New York Times, July 28

Critics Say Housing Bill Won’t Perform Miracles
- Washington Post,

Senate Passes Rescue Package for Homeowners
- Washington Post, July 28

Empowered Official Will Regulate Mortgage Giants
- Wall Street Journal ($), July 25

Judge, a ‘Friend of Angelo,’ Ruled for Countrywide
- Los Angeles Times, July 25

Founders of News Site Involved in Mortgages, Wachovia’s Ills
- New York Sun, July 25

Huge Housing Bill Set to Become Law
- Washington Post, July 24

SEC, Fed Officials Call on Lawmakers for Expanded Oversight of Banks
- Wall Street Journal ($), July 24

San Diego Sues BofA to Halt Foreclosures
- Reuters, July 24

Federal Grand Jury Investigating Countrywide, IndyMac, New Century
- Los Angeles Times, July 24

Senate Republicans Push Ban on Lobbying by Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac
- Politico, July 24

Lawmakers Move to Curb Pay at Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac
- AP, July 22

Mortgage Giant Rescue Could Cost $25 Billion
- AP, July 22

Thousands With Criminal Records Work Unlicensed as Loan Originators in Fla.
- The Miami Herald, July 21

In Depth: Americans Struggle With Rising Lenders’ Fees
- The New York Times, July 21

Some Banks Fear SEC Short-Sale Rule Makes Them Targets
- The Wall Street Journal ($), July 21

Gov’t Weighs More Charges in Bear Case
- Reuters, July 21

Gov’t Docs: FDIC Gave Out Some Predatory Subprime Loans
- The Wall Street Journal ($), July 21

New Regulator in Rescue Plan Spurs Debate
- The New York Times, July 21

Countrywide Filing Shines Light on Poor Quality Loans
- The Wall Street Journal ($), July 18

Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac Host GOP Convention Party
- Politico, July 18

Figures in Both Campaigns Have Deep Ties to Mortgage Giants
- Washington Post, July 17

Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac Invest in Dems
- Capital Eye, July 17

FBI Scrutinizes Failure of IndyMac Bank
- USA Today, July 17

Fed Crisis Role Spurs Questions of Overreach
- Washington Post, July 17

SEC Subpoenas Top Wall Street Firms in Hunt for Bear Stearns ‘Manipulators’
- Bloomberg News, July 16

Countrywide Settles Penn. Suit over Abusive Lending Practices
- The New York Times, July 16

Countrywide’s VIP Program In Depth
- Portfolio, July 16

Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac Spent $200 Million to Buy Influence
- Politico, July 16

Rivals Question Goldman Sachs About Bear’s Fall
- The Wall Street Journal ($), July 16

SEC to Limit Short Sales of Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac
- Bloomberg News, July 15

Fed Slaps New Rules on Mortgage Lenders to Curb Deceptive Lending
- Los Angeles Times, July 15

Mortgage Insurers Tighten Standards for Home Buyers
- The Wall Street Journal ($), July 15

Gov’t Report: Creditors Garnishing Protected Funds
- Washington Post, July 14

Sen. Schumer Deflects Blame for IndyMac Failure
- The Wall Street Journal ($), July 14

Citigroup’s $1.1 Trillion in Mysterious Assets
- Bloomberg News, July 14

SEC: Investment Banks Played Role in Subprime Meltdown
- Financial Week, July 14

IndyMac Bank Seized by Federal Regulators
- Los Angeles Times, July 14

Treasury Acts to Shore Up Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac
- The New York Times, July 14

Protected by Washington, Fannie and Freddie Ballooned
- The New York Times, July 14

SEC Warns Wall Street: Stop Spreading False Rumors
- The New York Times, July 14

Top Treasury Official Leaves to Head Troubled Bank
- Washington Post, July 11

Reporter: Bear Stearns Collapse Not Caused by On-Air Reports
- CNBC, July 10

SEC Report Details Problems at Top Three Credit Rating Firms
- The Wall Street Journal ($), July 8

Fed, SEC Team Up on Bank Oversight
- Washington Post, July 8

Fed to Clamp Down on Exotic and Subprime Loans
- The New York Times, July 8

Finance Group Questions Bond-Rating Proposals
- The Wall Street Journal ($), July 7

Housing Industry Ramps Up Political Donations
- The Wall Street Journal ($), July 7

Accounting Plan Allowing Use of Foreign Rules May Dilute Securities Regulation
- The New York Times, July 7

UBS Whistleblower Accuses Firm of Retaliation
- The Boston Globe, July 3

Fed. Housing Admin. Aims to Curb No-Money-Down Loan Program
- NPR, July 3

Countrywide’s PAC Closing Amid Inquiries
- The Washington Times, July 2

Moody’s Loses a Key Player Amid Error Probe
- The Wall Street Journal, July 2

Inside IndyMac’s Irresponsible Lending
- Center for Responsible Lending, July 1

Florida Sues Countrywide
- The Wall Street Journal, July 1

Credit Crunch Fuels Rise in ‘Advance Fee’ Schemes
- The Wall Street Journal, July 1

GOP Reps Call For Mortgage Probe – But Keep Their Countrywide Donations
- Roll Call, June 30

Subprime Credit Cards Come Under Greater Scrutiny
- McClatchy, June 30

Study: Subprime Loans Target Minority Neighborhoods
- Washington Post, June 30

Analysts: Housing Bill May Help Only a Fraction of Those in Need
- The New York Times, June 30

Inside The Collapse of Bear Stearns
- Vanity Fair, June 30

Countrywide CEO Helped Many Get Loans
- The Wall Street Journal, June 27

Homeowners Fight for their Mortgage Rights
- USA Today, June 26

How the Bear Stearns Fraud Case Unfolded
- NPR, June 26

Feds Probing Whether Bear Stearns Managers Misled Banks
- Business Week, June 26

Countrywide’s Pressures Mount
- The Wall Street Journal, June 26

99 Senators Offer Up Mortgage Details
- Politico, June 26

California Sues Countrywide
- Los Angeles Times, June 25

Vital Part of Housing Bill Is Brainchild of Banks
- Washington Post, June 25

Illinois Plans to Sue Countrywide, CEO
- The Wall Street Journal, June 25

Are we missing something? .

ProPublica Report

Enter your e-mail address
to receive our top stories daily.


© Copyright 2008 Pro Publica Inc. The original content on this site is licensed under a
Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 3.0 United States License.