Close Close Comment Creative Commons Donate Email Add Email Facebook Instagram Facebook Messenger Mobile Nav Menu Podcast Print RSS Search Secure Twitter WhatsApp YouTube
Stand up for journalism that holds the powerful to account.

Here’s How ProPublica Analyzed Bud Frazier’s Medicare Outcomes

Our analysis showed that Frazier, a heart surgery legend, had one of the highest one-year death rates in the nation for left ventricular assist device implantations in Medicare from 2010-2015.

ProPublica and the Houston Chronicle have concluded that Medicare patients whose left ventricular assist devices were implanted by Dr. O.H. “Bud” Frazier from 2010-2015 fared worse than those whose surgeries were performed by other physicians. During that time, about half of the traditional Medicare patients who received a heart assist device from Frazier died within a year, nearly double the national mortality rate, ProPublica’s analysis showed. Here’s how we did it:

ProPublica obtained Medicare hospital inpatient data and mortality data for 2010-2015 (specifically, the Medicare 100% Standard Analytic Files and Denominator Files). The data was submitted by hospitals to Medicare for billing purposes, and hospitals are responsible for its accuracy.

Each record in the data represents a patient’s hospital visit, indicating when the patient was admitted, what diagnoses were present, which procedures were performed, and the identity of the operating surgeon, if applicable. The data conceals patients’ identities. The data does not represent all patients, only those who are enrolled in fee-for-service Medicare.

For the purpose of our analysis, we looked at records submitted under diagnosis groups 001 and 002, which cover heart transplants and implantation of mechanical heart pumps, and then further looked for specific procedure codes that correspond to ventricular assist device implantation (37.66 under the ICD-9 schema and 02HA0QZ under ICD-10). In total, our analysis looked at 7,552 such inpatient visits; we excluded 27 cases for which we lacked data on whether the patient survived.

A small percentage of those inpatient visits (about 1 percent) included both the implantation of ventricular assist devices and heart transplants. We included such cases when calculating outcomes. Results are very similar if those cases are excluded. Some patients (about 4 percent) had more than one inpatient visit to implant a ventricular assist device in the years covered by our data.

We looked at data for surgeons at Baylor St. Luke’s Medical Center in Houston, as well as all other hospitals across the country. The patients we noted for Frazier were those for which the hospital itself listed Frazier as the primary operating surgeon. Other physicians may have assisted with the procedures.

Frazier was one of the highest-volume surgeons in the country for ventricular assist device implantations. His patients were about the same age as typical Medicare patients receiving the procedure. (His median patient was 64 years old, compared to 65 nationally.) Medicare covers both seniors and disabled people, thus some patients are under age 65.

We tallied the number of patients who died within one year of discharge. Mortality data came from both inpatient records and from Medicare denominator files, which we obtained for 2010-2015. Survival rates for 2015 operations are incomplete. Without the 2016 denominator file, not all 2015 procedures have a full year of follow up.

Frazier and St. Luke’s disputed our analysis for a number of reasons. St. Luke’s said that Medicare only accounts for half of the total cases it performs. The hospital also said that some ventricular assist devices are not billed under diagnosis groups 001 and 002 and that our analysis did not include all types of ventricular assist devices. Finally, St. Luke’s said that a billing record may not reflect all of the physicians on a case.

While Medicare does not cover all surgeries, researchers commonly use Medicare data to compare outcomes because it represents tens of millions of patients and because data for privately insured patients is not publicly available. All doctors are compared on this basis, so no one is disadvantaged by it.

We examined whether St. Luke’s billed for ventricular assist device implantation codes under other diagnosis groups and found none. Also, we did not include hospital visits with only implants of short-term devices, which appear in the data with procedure codes such as 37.60, 37.65, 02HA0RJ, 02HA0RS, or 02HA0RZ, because such devices are generally used in extreme conditions and outcomes are generally worse. Experts said it would be inappropriate to include them in an analysis of outcomes for implanted ventricular assist devices.

Filed under:

Protect Independent Journalism

This story you’ve just finished was funded by our readers. We hope it inspires you to make a gift to ProPublica so that we can publish more investigations like this one that hold people in power to account and produce real change.

ProPublica is a nonprofit newsroom that produces nonpartisan, evidence-based journalism to expose injustice, corruption and wrongdoing. We were founded over 10 years ago to fill a growing hole in journalism: Newsrooms were (and still are) shrinking, and legacy funding models are failing. Deep-dive reporting like ours is slow and expensive, and investigative journalism is a luxury in many newsrooms today — but it remains as critical as ever to democracy and our civic life. More than a decade (and six Pulitzer Prizes) later, ProPublica has built one of the largest investigative newsrooms in the country. Our work has spurred reform through legislation, at the voting booth and inside our nation’s most important institutions.

Your donation today will help us ensure that we can continue this critical work. From the climate crisis, to racial justice, to wealth inequality and much more, we are busier than ever covering stories you won’t see anywhere else. Make your gift of any amount today and join the tens of thousands of ProPublicans across the country, standing up for the power of independent journalism to produce real, lasting change. Thank you.

Donate Now

Portrait of Hannah Fresques

Hannah Fresques

Hannah Fresques is the deputy data editor at ProPublica.

Portrait of Olga Pierce

Olga Pierce

Olga Pierce is a reporter at ProPublica, specializing in data-driven stories.

Portrait of Charles Ornstein

Charles Ornstein

Charles Ornstein oversees the Local Reporting Network, as well as ProPublica offices in the Midwest, the South, the Southwest and a unit operated with The Texas Tribune.

Latest Stories from ProPublica

Current site Current page