Journalism in the Public Interest

Business & Finance, Education

Transcript: How Do Unpaid Internships Impact Industry?

Icon designed by Lorie, from The Noun Project

Earlier this week, David Dennis, an alum of Northwestern’s graduate school of journalism, argued in the Guardian that unpaid internships have changed the news industry for the worse.

Since students from low- and middle-class backgrounds often don’t have the means to accept unpaid internships, Dennis wrote, their chances of landing a job decrease. Subsequently, their perspectives are absent from news coverage. And that, Dennis wrote, “alienates a large portion of the American population.”

But it’s not just news companies offering unpaid internships, which made us wonder – how has the rise in internships (and especially unpaid internships) changed industries in the United States? What options are available to students who can’t afford unpaid internships? What role have schools played in promoting unpaid internships?

Writer David Dennis (@DavidDTSS), Guardian U.S. finance columnist Helaine Olen (@helaineolen) and Gina Neff Ph.D. (@ginasue), an associate professor at the University of Washington, joined the ProPublica and Guardian US communities Friday, May 31 for a discussion on how unpaid internships are impacting industry. Some key takeaways:

Not only are internships becoming a preqrequisite to landing a job, many universities and well-off suburban and private high schools are also now requiring students complete internships. However, systems for ensuring these internships are for the students' educational benefit are spotty. Neff noted that the University of Washington has a "great" legislative reporting internship that involves close faculty mentoring. However, her research found fewer than 10% of journalism and communications departments in the U.S. offered that level of engagement. 

A good mentor may be key to a good internship. Several participants that mentorship, from both faculty and companies, was the most valuable part of their internship. "Both in showing what a professionaly should really be like, and also for providing recommendations and networking," said commenter Jess. 

No one is really tracking the economic impact of unpaid internships.  "I have a friend in PR that went through 2 rounds of interviews for a job before being told they'd decided to split the position's work between two interns instead of hiring someone," said commenter Jess. And though interns are often doing the work of paid employees, it's unclear what that effect has been on the economy. A few academic studies have been done, but Neff noted that interns aren't considered part of the labor force by the Bureau of labor Statistics. That means they're not tracked.


blog comments powered by Disqus

Projects You Can Help With


Transcript: Are Drug Laws Punishing Innocent Mothers?

Read the Chat



Ask ProPublica Anything About Our Red Cross Investigation

Ask a Question


Transcript: Should Public Schools be Free to Pin Down Students?

Weigh In



Do You Know a Child Who’s Been Forcibly Restrained at School?

Share Your Story

100 tips submitted

More on This Investigation

What We Learned Investigating Unpaid Internships

Though the intern economy remains opaque, dialogue about the role of interns in the labor force – and protections they deserve – is beginning to take shape.

Four Ways You Can Seek Back Pay for an Unpaid Internship

Think you’re entitled to be paid for your unpaid internship? Here are resources you should know about.

Have You Interned in Arts or Entertainment? Rate Your Internship

Help us understand what it’s like to intern in an industry that often doesn’t pay.

The Department of Labor’s Internships Investigations

In 2010, the Labor Department issued a new fact sheet clarifying when an intern needs to be paid under federal labor law. We collected the case files for all the internship investigations the Labor Department concluded in the three years after issuing new regulations.

How the Labor Department Has Let Companies Off the Hook for Unpaid Internships

Four years after warning for-profit companies about unpaid internships, the agency has investigated relatively few employers for wage violations.