Journalism in the Public Interest

Eye on the Bailout

Homeowners Say Banks Not Following Rules for Loan Modifications

(Ethan Miller/Getty Images)

Nathan Reynolds is something of an expert on the government’s foreclosure prevention program. A mortgage broker who’s worked in the Chicago area since 1998, he’s seen both his business and his home’s value plummet in the past few years. After receiving his own trial loan modification from JPMorgan Chase, he’s helped others apply for modifications through the program on his own time.

But in November, after Reynolds had made trial loan payments for seven months, Chase told him his mortgage would not be permanently modified. Chase had determined that his personal financial troubles were only temporary — because Reynolds had expressed optimism that the administration’s policies might rescue the housing market, boosting his income.

That’s not a legitimate reason for a loan servicer to deny someone’s modification, according to the Treasury Department’s guidelines for the program. And Reynolds’ experience — along with the cases of two other homeowners examined by ProPublica, shows how servicers have created unnecessary hurdles that, in some instances, violate the loan program’s rules.


With Bank Money Returning, Bailout Burden Shifts Toward Housing

 The year ended with three of the biggest bailout recipients – Bank of America, Wells Fargo and Citigroup – together returning more than $90 billion to the Treasury Department. But it also ended with a Christmas Eve announcement from the Treasury that it could spend a virtually unlimited amount of money bailing out Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. So while the Treasury is winding down its programs to support the nation’s banks, it will continue to spend big to prop up the housing market.

As of the end of December, the bailout total outstanding fell to $337.5 billion, a decrease of $84 billion since our last monthly update. We continue to track the totals on our frequently updated bailout database*, which tracks both the TARP and the bailout of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac.

Meanwhile, the losses booked from the bailouts did not grow in December, staying around $9 billion. Treasury did, however, release its updated estimate for ultimate losses from the TARP: $61.1 billion. We’ll continue to track the losses as they’re realized.

And revenue continued to grow, reaching $20.6 billion. More about that below.


Loan Mod Program Delays Even Worse for Those Struggling Not to Fall Behind

Jim Banford from Real Estate Asset Disposition Corp. walks through one of the foreclosed properties his company is trying to resell in Jupiter, Fla. (Joe Raedle/Getty Images/April 2008)
Since last spring, when President Barack Obama announced his administration’s plan to prevent foreclosures, there’s been a crush of homeowners seeking help from mortgage servicers. Confusion and delays have plagued the entire program, but the problems have been particularly acute for homeowners seeking a modification before they begin falling behind on their mortgage payments.

Some homeowners, like Regan Sciesinski of Florida, have been waiting as long as nine months with no relief. The Sciesinskis seem to be a prime candidate for a modification through the program. His wife, Stacy, was found to have breast cancer in late 2007, and in the past year, a combination of medical costs and reduced income have made their mortgage payments unaffordable for the couple, who have three children. Their home, in a suburb of Tampa, has also dropped about 25 percent in value since they bought it in 2006. Like millions of other homeowners, they’re underwater, stuck with mortgages worth more than the property.

Sciesinski says he first submitted his information to his servicer, Chase Home Finance, in March. He’s still waiting. Sciesinski says he and his wife have drained their retirement savings and accepted help from other family members to stay current. "We take our obligation seriously," he says, but now they’re facing default and need the modification "because having to move would completely devastate us."


Bank Failure Friday: 7 Banks Go Down, 3 with No Buyer

It was another busy Friday for regulators, as they closed seven banks, bringing this year’s total to 140. As always, we’ve updated our complete list of failed banks.

The failures figure to continue in 2010. FDIC Chair Sheila Bair said last month failures will “peak” next year. The FDIC’s recently announced budget for 2010 reflects that: In order the handle bank closings, the agency plans to add 1,600 temporary employees to its staff of about seven thousand. The FDIC said last month that its list of “problem” banks has risen to 552.

All told, Friday’s failures cost the FDIC about $1.8 billion. The agency earlier this year dealt with its deficit by arranging for insured banks to prepay three years of assessments in advance, which is expected to raise $45 billion.

Read more ...

Not Everybody Loses on Bank Failure Friday

Three more banks failed on Friday, bringing the year's total to 133. The FDIC estimates Friday's failures will cost its insurance fund a combined $252.1 million. While the failures represent another hit to the FDIC's depleted fund, they are a boon to three companies that acquired the assets and deposits of the closed institutions.

The first to go for the day was Republic Federal Bank of Miami, Florida. The bank had total assets of approximately $433 million and deposits of approximately $352.7 million. 1st United Bank of Boca Raton assumed all the deposits of the failed bank, paying the FDIC a premium of 1.2 percent for them. It also purchased $267.1 million of the failed bank's assets including loans, cash and marketable investment securities.


About This Project

We're tracking where the bailout money is going. Our lead bailout reporter – and blogger – is ProPublica's Paul Kiel. Lead developer is Dan Nguyen.


  • Our frequently updated database tracks every dollar. In the scorecard, we provide a summary generated from the latest numbers.
Photo by flickr user sparkieblues


Latest Episode: We recently relaunched our podcast, in which journalists tell us how they nailed their biggest stories. Now we want to hear from you.

Listen »

Latest Bailout Activity

Loading latest bailouts feed...

Get Updates

Our Hottest Stories