ProPublica

Journalism in the Public Interest

Cancel

Eric Umansky and NYU’s Jay Rosen Discuss Explanatory Journalism Project

Last week, ProPublica announced a partnership with NYU's Carter Journalism Institute to explore how we can use the Web to do better explanatory journalism.

We sat down with the drivers of the partnership–professor Jay Rosen and senior editor Eric Umansky – to discuss the project, which is being led by NYU. Jay and Eric discuss the motivation behind the effort, why it fits ProPublica’s mission, and the circuitous nature of the journalism world.

“The world is a complex place with a lot of stories to follow and a lot of tangents,” Eric Umansky says. “Orienting people and contextualizing things is a fundamental part” of good journalism.

To listen to the podcast, scroll to the bottom of this post. 

Articles discussed in this podcast:

NYU and ProPublica Team Up to Experiment With Explanatory Journalism

Video explainer on CDOs

 

Transcript:


Studio 20 Collaboration

Hi. I'm Mike Webb, and welcome to the ProPublica podcast. Last week, ProPublica announced a new partnership with New York University's Studio 20 Program at the Carter Journalism Institute to explore how we can use the Web to do better explanatory journalism. Senior editor Eric Umansky will be in charge of the project for ProPublica and professor Jay Rosen will head things up for NYU. And they're both here to talk about what it is and how it will work.

Mr. Umansky was a former columnist for Slate and he's written for several news organizations, including the New York Times Magazine, Washington Post, The New Republic and he is the former editor of motherjones.com.

Rosen has been a member of NYU's faculty since 1986, and he is a press critic and reviewer whose work has been published in The Nation, Columbia Journalism Review, The Chronicle of Higher Education, and various other major newspapers and Websites. Welcome to the program, guys.

Mike: Jay, I'm going to start with you. Can you explain what you mean by explanatory journalism and the ways you think that we can improve it?

Jay: Sure. The way the news system was built, before the Web, people often started to receive news items and updates about stories that they didn't necessarily have the background for. And people often are coming in the middle of the movie. And journalists do their best to try and catch up those users to what had gone on. But it wasn't an important part of the news system because there wasn't space and there wasn't time. So, explanatory journalism is providing the necessary background knowledge to understand and follow the news. And this is where our project is aimed.

Mike: OK. Well, Eric, why is that important to ProPublica? How does that fit in with what we do?

Eric Umansky: Sure. Well, it fits in a number of ways. I mean, at ProPublica, we deal with, obviously, accountability stories, and they also often happen to be enormously complex stories. To give you an example, we follow the foreclosure and mortgage crisis very closely. We write about it a number of times a week. And I don't know about other folks, but it makes my mind hurt to try to follow it. And so, one of the things that we've done is we've done facts and primers, and all sorts of stuff to help people understand what's going on.

It's very difficult to do good journalism. It's very difficult to understand, to really have stuff resonate without understanding the basic parameters of the story.

Mike: Right. OK. Well, Jay, what was your basic motivation for this?

Jay: It started two years ago when I listened to The Giant Pool of Money, This American Life's one hour documentary about the mortgage crisis, done in partnership with NPR. And I listened to it twice because it was so good at doing what Eric just explained. And I realized afterwards that I started to follow the news about the subprime mortgage mess because I now had the necessary knowledge for doing that. And this interested me as a student of the future of news. And I wrote about it in a post called National Explainer then, tried to make the point that we often think of explanation as coming late in the process. After news, after analysis, after editorializing, somebody might do a big explanation. But I think it's really the opposite. Until we have this basic background knowledge or context, we actually aren't customers for the news.

I then put together with my colleague, Matt Thompson of NPR, a panel. It's South by Southwest, which is a big news media conference in Austin where we grappled with this problem, which we called the Future of Context. And the room was sold out and there were many aftershocks after that event. And it was clear to me that lots of people were on to this problem, and it wasn't just something that interested me. It was clearly a kind of hole in the news system as it stands.

And I had this graduate program, Studio 20, where we try to teach the journalists of the future by plunging them into interesting, new, innovative projects with media partners. And it seemed like working on this problem with ProPublica would be a perfect project for that graduate program. So, that's how it all came together.

Eric: Yeah, and I would say, just to reiterate what Jay said, that Giant Pool of Money which was done by the group that's now Planet Money, who we love and we've worked with a number of times and we're continuing to work with. I remember a line from that show, and I think it was Ira Glass who was describing the process of what Jay is saying about feeling on the outside with stories and with news events, and not really understanding them, and watching them go by. I believe his line was, "I sat out the Bosnian War." It was just too complicated to understand. And each day, there would be these dispatches from this place or that place. But you couldn't really get oriented very easily. The world is a complex place, and there are a lot of stories to follow and a lot of tangents. And orienting people and contextualizing things is, I think, a fundamental part.

Mike: I've always found it a little confusing, or confounding may be a better word, because sometimes you're reading a story and you know enough that you don't need the background information that they're inserting in it. But you don't have the full orientation as you guys said.

Eric: I think that's where the Web can be enormously helpful in re-envisioning what these things can be, because you can be stuck in the old format. You had a paragraph or two to provide background, and that's it. And as Jay was saying earlier, you get hemmed in by that. And you have this boilerplate language that makes sense to some people, and is old hat to other people.

With the Web you can have a kind of strategic depth. If you want more, you can get more. If you want to understand more, you can get it. But you don't have to.

Jay: What we're trying to do is take the added flexibility of the Web that Eric just described and the wider range of tools that journalists have available to them; not just text, but graphics and photo and video and audio and data, and get a dividend for users and understanding out of these advances. And that's one of the things that the project is going to experiment with.

Mike: And Eric, ProPublica has done some of these in the past, right?

Eric: Yeah. We've had the kind of...

Mike: Something like it, at least.

Eric: Yeah. Well, we've had the kind of explainers that I was mentioning earlier, the kind of backgrounder pieces. So, a fact about the Gulf Oil Spill. What's known? What's not? Facts about wrongful foreclosures or the foreclosure process. One of the things is we've also done it in different ways with our own stories, tried to do it in creative ways. So we had this very complex story that I actually was the editor on from a few months ago and that we did with the Planet Money folks and with This American Life about banks doing shady things, basically, in the run up to the crisis. And these were enormously difficult things to understand. And one of the ways we approached it, we ended up doing a comic, and in another story we did a Broadway song. Our feeling is, whatever it takes to help people understand the story and to really try to have an open mind about that.

Mike: Right. Well now, how closely do you guys envision students working with our staff, with ProPublica staff?

Jay: It's already been pretty close. We've had students come down to four planning meetings, at ProPublica. We are sending graduate students to the newsroom to conduct interviews with key editors and reporters at ProPublica so that we can really understand how they work. And we're going to get editorial priorities from ProPublica before we start to make anything for them.

We also anticipate Eric and his colleagues coming to class semi-regularly throughout the spring term of 2011. The idea is to make stuff that ProPublica can use. So there's no way to do that without engaging with ProPublica staff, and that's the real value of the project for the students.

Eric: Yeah, and we have, I believe one of our reporters, Charlie Ornstein, just met with a student today. I'm chatting with a student later today. I mean, these aren't easy things to solve, and we're eager to get the ball rolling.

Jay: One of the things we already found, Mike, is that just by announcing this project this week, which we didn't mention; we have found other people who are very interested in this, who want to contribute to it. Because as I said earlier, this is a problem in the news system as a whole that many people recognize.

There's a fellow at the Knight Fellows Program at Stanford University who is devoting his entire fellowship year to this problem, who emerged when we announced it. Another thing that the students are doing is they're extending the search across a very broad cultural space for people who can contribute to this project.

And for this kind of effort, I think ProPublica, being a non‑profit and having such a strong interest in not just producing journalism, but educating journalism to be better, is the perfect partner.

Eric: And by the way, just to interject for a second. The guy you just mentioned, at Stanford, who is doing the Knight Fellowship, his name is Paddy Hirsch.

Just to take it all to a careful circle, Paddy Hirsch is one of the producer's at Marketplace Radio.

Mike: Perfect.

Eric: Marketplace Radio, which not only does great work generally, but did the single best explainer that I have seen ever...

Mike: Most definitely.

Eric:...explaining collateralized debt obligations.

Mike: We're going to have to send that to you, Jay.

Eric: Yeah, Paddy Hirsch did the [best] video. He did it as writing on a whiteboard. And he actually turned it into a series, I think. A semi-regular series where he called it "The Whiteboard" or something, and each week he would have a new, just a two or three minute video explaining some other complex part of Wall Street and economics. In fact, it was such a great video that we have linked to it in just about every story that we've done on CDOs.

Jay: Yeah, that's another way of explaining this project is, that's a very good example. The more forbidding the subject is, and the more important it is to public accountability, the more we need the art of the explainer.

Mike: Well, guys, as an avid news consumer, I'm really excited about this and I'm glad that we're working together to make this happen.

Mike: Thanks a lot for joining us, Jay, Eric. You can see samples of explainers at propublica.org/investigations.

Jay: And don't forget explainer.net.

Mike: All right, take care.

Now for our Officials Say Tumblr quote of the week. "If Amazon is so uncomfortable with the first amendment, they should get out of the business of selling books." That's from WikiLeaks. You can check it out at officialssay.tumblr.com.

That's our podcast for the week. We've got some exciting investigations coming, so be sure to check out propublica.org often. Thanks for listening. This podcast was produced by Quadia Muhammad. For ProPublica, I'm Mike Webb. We'll see you next week.

Transcription by CastingWords

I need to contact site admin urgently. Can you understand me?   
Thanks

Зацените сайтик: <a >4Leaf MPEG Video Converter v1.9.3 by Sixeco
</a>

snitteeideaks

Dec. 20, 2010, 2:56 a.m.

Hello, excuse what not on tell me please where enohpelet<a >?</a>

effecearrolve

Dec. 22, 2010, 6:33 a.m.

Битва Титанов / Clash of the Titans (2010) BDRip (720p) от HD-Zona-X,
VA - New Music vol. 79 from @nGeL® (2010)
<a >MP3</a>, <a >Аватар: Легенда об Аанге </a>(Книга 3: Огонь) /Avatar: The Legend Of Aang (Book 3: Fire)/ DVDRip , VA - New Music vol. 48 from @nGeL® (2010) MP3 от BUTOVOgroup,
<a >VA - Самый хитовый сборник</a> , <a >Баба-Яга учится читать / A Baba-Yaga studies to read (2003) PC</a>, VA - New Music vol. 66 from @nGeL® (2010) MP3,
<a >Американский психопат</a>/American Psycho(2000), Аниме обои (Большой пак - часть 2)

waikeLattture

Dec. 22, 2010, 3:39 p.m.

Киевский центральный автовокзал, электрическая схема форд фокус, mitsubishi книги купить galant, электрическая схема hyundai, mitsubishi chariot grandis Запчасти Субару Импреза Форестер Легаси Аутбек Трибека Subaru Impreza Forester Legacy ФОТО СУБАРУ SUBARU FOTO Subaru Foto Фото Субару ФОТО АУТБЕК ЛЕГАСИ Продажа авто, автомобиль, объявление, Продажа бу Daihatsu Grand Move Черновцы, Авто Автомобили Авто базар.

Uebernachtung Guenstige

Dec. 31, 2010, 2:32 p.m.

War Whom,criticism receive defendant powerful public fact wine garden terrible happen item exercise hell belief likely drive season deep heavy announce shop bank capital indicate us myself latter need claim display river below lead loss critical well transport secretary long appeal alone start large growing arrive educational charge failure quality live great ticket manager file teach jump yes hotel race begin increase negotiation responsible couple relationship far compare help though recognition capable pretty lack off than unable application this government date sign credit selection popular fine improvement might

<font color=red>
Get at any of these exceedingly bargain-priced (Literally a tiny little fraction of the selling price)!!!!!
Email message me at buybreastactives @  gmail.com, so I can tell you how much. Feel free to inquire about for any items that are not on this listing.
(These arent the whole thing… there are about 25,000 total titles availalble.)
</font>


Muay Thai from Thai TV, 2009-08-23, Channel 7 Stadium XviD/DivX
Inside•MMA•06•04•2010•720p•x264•BluntzRip x264
UFC 97 Redemption DVDRip XviD-KYR <Extras>only]  XviD/DivX
World MMA Awards 2009 XviD-Zeus avi XviD/DivX
UFC 115 post fight press conference Other
<UFC>88] Dong Hyun Kim vs Matt Brown 2008-09-06 www kimjudas blogspot com XviD/DivX
SIRIUS Fight Club - 06/01/2010 MP3
StrikeForce•Evolution•FullEvent•720p•x264•BluntzRip x264
Inside MMA 2010 10 22 HDTV XviD-KYR XviD/DivX
sengoku 6 full event x264 x264
Dan Severn - Evolution of a Champion vol1-4 All Parts Xvid XviD/DivX
Boxing Career - Jake Lamotta XviD/DivX
SBGi Spring Camp 2004 XviD/DivX
Jake Ellenberger vs Jose Pele Landi Jons 10 03 2007 MPEG/xVCD
2010 IBJJF Pan <CAM>  WMV/ASF
Pride FC Final Conflict Absolute DVDRip XviD-KYR XviD/DivX
Roberto Abreu CYBORG-Seminar MPEG/xVCD
UFC 110 Nogueira vs Velasquez 720p HDTV x264-UFIGHTERS x264
Keith The Dean of Mean Jardine 16 fights XviD/DivX
UFC 112 - Silva Vs Maia XviD/DivX
<K>1 WGP in Seoul] Yong Soo Park vs Singh Heart Jaideep 2009-08-02 XviD/DivX
UFC 104 Prelims HDTV XviD-BigTex XviD/DivX
UFC 110 Fighter Previews Flv-HLP Other
DREAM 7 - Atsushi Yamamoto vs Masakazu Imanari xvid XviD/DivX
The Ultimate Fighter S11 Special Road to the Finale 720p HDTV x264-aAF *unrar’d, working*  x264
Shinya Aoki highlight by Damien WMV/ASF
Mark Hatmaker - Armor Plated Disc 1 <DVDRip>  XviD/DivX
Kettlebell Secrets Audio Series MP3
Diet Analysis+ 8 0 Weight Loss Application Other
Red Zone Knife Defence XviD/DivX
Bellator•14•Full Event•720p•x264•BluntzRip x264
UFC 121 Lesnar vs Velasquez Pre Fight Press Conference wmv WMV/ASF
Robert Drysdale Nth Dimension Jiu Jitsu - Vol 6 The Body Lock And Other Nth Dimension Attacks DVDRip XviD XviD/DivX
Before The Bell UFC 92 XviD IceMan XviD/DivX
Combat Sambo with Master Tony Lopez Volume 9 Street Fighting Dirty Tricks avi XviD/DivX
K-1 fightnight 1997 DVD
K-1 HEROs Season 2005 COMPLETE PAL DVD9x3-HiTS DVD
Dream 14 HDTV XViD-KYR XviD/DivX
Jose Junior Aldo MMA Career 13 of 17 fights BJJ Elite XviD/DivX
Best of Shooto 2007 Volume 1 DVD
The Noble Art of Muay Thai DVD
UFC 114 Rampage vs Evans 720p HDTV x264-BOV x264
HDNet Fights Yarennoka Fedor Returns HDTV XviD-KYR HDTV
UFC 104 Countdown PDTV XviD-MaM XviD/DivX
Randy Couture Learn To Fight and Win! 01 Special Tactics DVD
UFC 98 Krzysztof Soszynski vs Andre Gusmao SDRIP x264 x264
UFC Live Versus 1 Pre Pack XviD-UPiNSMOKE XviD/DivX
UFC 110 Countdown 720p HDTV X264-KYR x264
UFC 124 Countdown HDTV XviD-BOV   for 25d 1210 HDTV
Paragon BJJ - Secrets of our Success BJJ Elite DVD

acquire UFC 79 Nemesis 720p HDTV x264-CtrlHD x264 Anderson Silva Boxing For MMA 2009 NTSC DVDR-OSS DVD ufc115 pressconference WMV/ASF evaluation
purchase ken cohen qigong course MPEG/xVCD K-1 World GP 2010 in Bucharest REPACK 720p HDTV x264-WB x264 Ricardo Mayorga vs Shane Mosley - HBO - Vacant WBA Inter-Continental Light Middleweight Title XviD/DivX program review
acquire Paul Williams vs Kermit Cintron - HD-Source Xvid XviD/DivX Deadliest Warrior S02E07 HDTV XviD-aAF HDTV The best moments OF Pride WMV/ASF article
shop for Sengoku•11th•Battle•720p•x264•BluntzRip x264 Erich Schiffmann - Beginning Yoga m4v x264 Tony Psalia Wing Chun seminars XviD/DivX review article
shop for UFC 98 Krzysztof Soszynski vs Andre Gusmao SDRIP x264 x264 Strikeforce Heavy Artillery PPV HDTV XviD-XS XviD/DivX Inoki Bom-Ba-Ye 2003 - Inoki Festival DVD professional review
find 2009 11 27 The MMA Show XviD-JR XviD/DivX Yanagi流  tessenè¡“, tantō術, kusarigamaè¡“, jutteè¡“, and hojoè¡“  XviD/DivX Yoga Journal - Yoga For Relaxation And Meditation DVD DVD read
get hold of Extract Pages From Russian Muscle & Fitness 1209 pdf Other Cutting the Line DVD2 FMA DVD Yoga for regular guys 3 DVD set RIP XviD/DivX review
buy Hellbows - Elbow Techniques by James Keating DVD Rip XviD/DivX Hapkido GHF Danbong KOR XviD/DivX the 3rd man by boondock hl MPEG/xVCD review
acquire Underground Grip Fighting Secrets D5 BJJ Elite DVD Best Of Gladiator Challenge <E>2] XviD-JR XviD/DivX Ted LucayLucay Pocket Stick evaluation
get hold of How to Locate Acupuncture Points-The Definitive DVD DVDRip XviD/DivX Yarennoka - New Years Eve 2007 JPN PPV Ver,  XviD/DivX Fighting Words with Mike Straka 2010 05 14 Bas Rutten HDTV XviD-KYR XviD/DivX discussion
acquire Ryan Lee Boot Camp 2005 Underground Strength Coach LIVE Disc 1<DVDRip>  XviD/DivX HBO Boxing Mayweather vs Mosley Main Event 720p HDTV x264-WB x264 <DREAM>12] Full Event part 1 2009-10-25 XviD/DivX review article
use Roy Dean Blue Belt Requirements Disc 1&2 XviD XviD/DivX WEC 45 HDTV XViD-KYR HDTV Dillman - Tape 9 - PERSONALLY PREFERRED PRESSURE POINTS DVD assessment
pick up 05 <K>1 Dynamite] Hideo Tokoro vs Daisuke Nakamura www kimjudas blogspot com XviD/DivX Fedor Emelianenko <full>Career Pack]  Other Deadliest Warrior S2x02 Attila The Hun vs Alexander The Great XviD/DivX testimonial
get hold of Thiago Alves Career Update XviD/DivX Haganah F I G H T Knife and Gun Disarm DVDRip XviD-UPiNSMOKE XviD/DivX UFC Ultimate 100 Greatest Fights Part 2 HDTV XviD-KYR HDTV discussion
shop for UFC 118 Edgar vs Penn 2 DSR XviD-XWT XviD/DivX Wanderlei Silva vs Quinton Jackson 3 TZMMA avi XviD/DivX UFC 113 Machida vs Shogun 2 Weigh-Ins 720p HDTV x264-WB x264 testimonial
obtain Inside MMA 2009 05 01 HDTV XviD-KYR HDTV SIRIUS Fight Club - 10/07/2010 MP3 Combat Sambo Chemp of Russia 2008 Russian MMA wis Gi XviD/DivX rating
obtain BJJ Sweeps by Flavio Almeida - XviD Version XviD/DivX UFC•116•Shane Carwin vs Brock Lesnar•x264•BluntzRip x264 Easy techniques for Self Defense - Gene Simco - vol 1 XviD/DivX professional review
buy Chris Arreola vs Vitali Klitschko HBO 9-26-2009 frisco008 avi XviD/DivX UFC 113 Post Fight Press Conference-Bm Divx XviD/DivX Yoga conditioning for athletes Rodney Yee XviD/DivX professional review
acquire 2010 05 23 Jewels - 8th Ring XviD/DivX UFC•115•Matt Wiman vs Mac Danzig•BluntzRip x264 <DREAM>8] Andre Galvao vs John Alessio www kimjudas blogspot com x264 evaluation
obtain JT Torres - Back Attack Secrets All-in-One NTSC DVD Ultimate Back Attacks DVD K-1 World MAX 2009 Final 16 HDTV XviD-KYR XviD/DivX UFC Ultimate Insider Episode 2 XviD/DivX testimonial
look for Stefan Struve - Career Pack XviD/DivX Fight News - UFC 104 Preview Xvid-JR XviD/DivX Dream 11 REPACK HDTV XviD-KYR XviD/DivX review
deal Vitali Klitschko vs Kevin Johnson - Sky Sports XviD/DivX Killer of the Amazon - Ronaldo Jacare HL by Hero1 XviD/DivX Paul Greenhill OG Clinic 3 Disc 2 BJJ Elite DVD guide
get hold of Barefoot Running HDTV Gustavo Dantas Advanced BJJ 1-7 King Of The Cage KOTC 5 - Cage Wars DVDRip rus XviD/DivX discussion
acquire Marcelo Garcia vs Kron Gracie XviD/DivX Starting Strength 2nd Edition by Mark Rippetoe Other UFC 92 Forrest Griffin vs Sugar Rashad Evans XviD/DivX read
find Crunch Fitness-Joy of Yoga avi XviD/DivX Strikeforce San Jose Diaz vs Noons II Post-Fight Interviews 1080p XviD-UPiNSMOKE XviD/DivX UFC 93 Post Fight XviD IceMan XviD/DivX report
look for Bak MeiWhite Eyebrow-Essential Exercises,Little Cross Form&Applications;,Tiger Hand Form&Applications; XviD/DivX Maphilindo Silat - Vol 1-2 by Rick Tucci XviD/DivX Submission Wrestling Finnish Open 2003 cd1of2 MPEG/xVCD review article
buying Bitetti Combat 8 XViD - MMAT XviD/DivX Strikeforce Challengers 2009 Evangelista vs Gurgel 720p HDTV x264-WB x264 UFC 2 - No Way Out - Retail DVD DVD reviewed
acquire national cup bjj 2009 XviD/DivX Penthouse MagazineBrock Lesnar Article - July-August 2010 Other Rumble On The Rock 1 DVD synopsis
buy Over 140 Grappling Drills XviD/DivX KJ Noons - Career Pack Other Gustavo Badell - Weight Training Workout Video - Titans 6 <> DVD Rip]  XviD/DivX report
obtain Demian Maia Science of Jiu Jitsu - Vol 1 Defending The Guard Pass DVDRip XviD XviD/DivX UFC 89 Bisping vs Leben 720p HDTV x264-aAF x264 William Cheung Wing Chun Rarities XviD/DivX article
buy Snap No Tap 7 Volume DVD Set with Tony Cecchine DVDRip XviD-UPiNSMOKE XviD/DivX Rick Young - Empty Hand Kali XviD/DivX The Cross Guard by Tinguinha - XviD Version XviD/DivX reviewed
look for Gray Cooks Functional movement screen XviD/DivX Koordinationstraining für Budo-Sportler DVD Chess On The Mat - Ricardo De La Riva Other report
get Chris Kent Dynamic JKD Vol 3~4 Other PBS Wide Angle - Victory Is Your Duty XviD/DivX Dana White talking about the Rampage retirement on the radio with Carmichael Dave MP3 guide

SucharaRedkoe

Jan. 4, 2011, 4:29 p.m.

Hi their, i created acclimatization

Not indigence to attend. I digs that he did and he is until this eye development

auto meter dpss auto garage los angeles price car quotes auto custom gas caps register car off road

SpupesadoSaks

Jan. 27, 2011, 7:08 a.m.

Layer styles are great for other special effects, too.

Зацените <a >папайя диета
</a>

реферат приемы ораторского мастерства
  <a >www</a>

реферат на тему природные зоны африки
  <a >www</a>

Add a comment

Email me when someone responds to this article.

Subscribe

Get Updates

Stay on top of what we’re working on by subscribing to our email digest.

optional

Our Hottest Stories

  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •