Journalism in the Public Interest


Who’s Responsible for Deaths Caused by Mixing up Infants’ and Children’s Tylenol?

Who's most responsible?
Add Your Reaction

Question: Who's most responsible for infant deaths?


Powered by ReadrBoard: Tell us what you think by highlighting any phrase or comment and adding your reaction. 


A few things to know:

• McNeil Consumer Healthcare, the Johnson & Johnson unit that makes Tylenol, and the Food and Drug Administration both knew for 15 years about the sometimes-lethal confusion over its Tylenol products for infants and children. Drop for drop, the strength of Infant’s Tylenol used to far exceed that of Children’s Tylenol. By confusing the products and administering too much of the infant’s version, parents or caretakers could inadvertently overdose their children.

• Aware of the problem, McNeil continued to sell the products as it pleaded with the Food and Drug Administration to add a dosing label that the company believed would solve the problem. The current label instructs consumers to call a doctor to get dosing instructions for children under two — but there is ample evidence that even healthcare providers sometimes mix up the products and give the wrong dosing instructions. McNeil wanted the FDA to add specific instructions by age and weight.

As of 2011, McNeil and other acetaminophen makers voluntarily agreed to stop selling two different concentrations of pediatric products. Today, infants’ and Children’s Tylenol have the same concentration, eliminating the potential confusion between two formulations.

• The FDA, has yet to take formal action. It has not mandated a single concentration. Nor has it decided whether to implement McNeil’s suggestion to add dosing information for kids under two.

blog comments powered by Disqus
blog comments powered by Disqus

Projects You Can Help With

More on This Investigation

FDA Opens Review of Rules for Over-the-Counter Drugs, Including Acetaminophen

Federal regulators’ announcement that they will examine the regulation of non-prescription drugs such as acetaminophen, the active ingredient in Tylenol, follows a ProPublica investigation.

Schumer Calls on Drug Makers to Add Safety Devices to Children’s Medicines Within a Year

Flow restrictors -- safety valves that cost pennies per bottle -- could save thousands of kids from being rushed to emergency rooms each year, but most children’s medications still don’t have them.

Over-The-Counter Pills Left Out of FDA Acetaminophen Limits

Federal drug regulators are moving to enforce a ban on prescription drugs with more than 325 milligrams of acetaminophen. But you’ll still be able to buy pills that contain up to twice that dose over-the-counter at the gas station or grocery store.

The Fix Isn’t In: Why a Safety Device That Can Stop Overdoses by Kids Isn’t Widely Used

Safety valves that cost pennies per bottle could save thousands of kids from being rushed to emergency rooms each year. A doctor has campaigned to have the devices added to all liquid medicines, but so far he’s had limited success.