ProPublica

Journalism in the Public Interest

Cancel

BP Agrees to Plead Guilty to Crimes in Gulf Oil Spill

The Justice Department indicts three BP managers for their roles in the Deepwater Horizon disaster and its aftermath. The company also will pay a $4.5 billion fine, the largest ever levied on a corporation.

Oil burns during a controlled fire in the Gulf of Mexico after the 2010 Deepwater Horizon drilling rig explosion, which killed 11 workers and sent as much as 200 million gallons of oil into the gulf. (U.S. Navy photo by Mass Communication Specialist 2nd Class Justin Stumberg/Released)

BP agreed to plead guilty today to charges of manslaughter, environmental crimes, and lying to Congress in connection with the 2010 Deepwater Horizon drilling rig explosion, which killed 11 workers and sent as much as 200 million gallons of oil into the Gulf of Mexico.

As part of a settlement with the U.S. Department of Justice, the company will pay $4.5 billion in what is the largest fine ever levied on a corporation in the United States.

The charges against the company stem from BP engineers' decision to ignore a critically important pressure test on the Macondo well structure that could have prevented the deadly blowout and explosion, and for misrepresenting the amount of oil leaking from the open well head after the mammoth drilling rig sank in nearly 5,000 feet of water.

In a separate and unexpected set of charges, three BP managers were indicted for their roles in operating the rig and for misrepresenting facts to Congress, marking the first time that any senior BP personnel have been criminally charged for their roles in the disaster.

According to a statement issued by the Department of Justice, Robert Kaluza and Donald Vidrine — the highest-ranking BP supervisors on board the Deepwater Horizon at the time of the accident — have been charged with gross negligence in their oversight of the safety tests being conducted on the Macondo well the night of the disaster.

Kaluza and Vidrine "observed clear indications that the Macondo well was not secure and that oil and gas were flowing into the well," the statement said, and then "chose not to take obvious and appropriate steps to prevent the blowout."

Each man has been charged with 11 counts of manslaughter, 11 counts of involuntary manslaughter and one violation of the Clean Water Act. The manslaughter counts each carry a maximum penalty of up to 10 years in prison.

In addition, BP's former deputy incident commander and the company's second-highest ranking person during the spill response, David Rainey, was charged with obstruction of Congress and making false statements to law enforcement officials.

According to the Department of Justice's statement, Rainey manipulated internal estimates to understate the amount of oil flowing from the well and withheld data that contradicted BP's public estimate of 5,000 barrels of oil per day, even though the company's internal calculations suggested a much higher amount.

Rainey could face up to 10 years in prison.

None of the men charged were available for comment, but lawyers for Kaluza and Vidrine told Bloomberg that their clients were innocent.

The Justice Department previously filed charges against a former BP employee, engineer Kurt Mix, alleging that he destroyed evidence in the early days of the disaster, but today's charges targeted higher-level employees with supervisory responsibility.

As part of the corporate agreement, BP pleaded guilty to 11 felony counts of misconduct or neglect relating to the 11 deaths and one felony count of obstruction of Congress, according to a statement issued by the company. It also pleaded guilty to two misdemeanor counts, one under the Clean Water Act, the other under the Migratory Bird Treaty Act.

"All of us at BP deeply regret the tragic loss of life caused by the Deepwater Horizon accident as well as the impact of the spill on the Gulf coast region," said Bob Dudley, BP's Group Chief Executive, in a statement issued by the company. "We apologize for our role in the accident, and as today's resolution with the U.S. government further reflects, we have accepted responsibility for our actions."

The criminal settlement is separate from the $7.8 billion agreement BP reached with Gulf plaintiffs earlier this year. It also does not resolve the outstanding civil suits brought against the company by states and the federal government, which could cost the company as much as additional $22 billion.

The charges for negligent interpretation of engineering tests on the ill-fated Macondo well set up the next battle for the company, as it prepares to defend against civil lawsuits and an assessment of fines under the Oil Pollution Control Act. A trial on that matter is expected to begin in February. It was not immediately clear whether today's settlement would trigger dramatically higher environmental fines — depending on the degree of negligence, BP could have to pay the government as much as $4,300 for each barrel of oil spilled in the Gulf.

The settlement also opens the door to debarment proceedings against the company — a possible ban on government contracts, including new leases, that is triggered by a criminal conviction. The Environmental Protection Agency has been evaluating BP for debarment since its deadly 2005 refinery explosion in Texas City, followed by an oil spill in Alaska in 2006. ProPublica reported extensively on the possibility of BP's debarment in 2010.

The agency had been awaiting a resolution in the Gulf matter before reaching a decision, sources tell ProPublica.

There was no immediate comment from EPA officials about debarment following today's announcement. In its statement, BP acknowledged the potential debarment consequences and said that it had not received word on whether debarment was still being considered.

The largest portion of BP's fine, almost $2.4 billion, will be paid to the National Fish & Wildlife Foundation over a period of five years, according to BP's statement. The National Academy of Sciences will receive $350 million. The rest will go mostly to cover criminal penalties, with another $525 million to go to the Securities and Exchange Commission to settle securities claims.

"We specifically structured this resolution to ensure that more than half of the proceeds directly benefit the Gulf Coast region so that residents can continue to recover and rebuild," said Attorney General Eric Holder, in a statement.

Abrahm Lustgarten, who reported on the BP oil spill for ProPublica, is the author of Run to Failure: BP and the Making of the Deepwater Horizon Disaster.

So, they sacrifice a few managers (what’s their history with the company, I wonder?) and pay a small fraction of their record profits, and they got to do it essentially on their terms.

Hooray for the Department of Justice.  Hip-hip…

No takers…?  Oh, well.

Wait, the SEC!?  Huh??

Why does it take someone getting killed to get action?
Here i blew the whistle on my employer Trico Lift and was fired for it 6 weeks later and get this even on that day 4/20/09 exactley one year before deepwater disaster Trico Lift sent into a SUNOCO refinery a 5 ton machine i just locked out unsafe with a major steering problem where the manufacturer even has a recall out on with an upgrade kit to properly repair this.Trico Lift did not stock this kit and was in a rush to get that machine in that refinery! The steering cylinder was already 90% out of it’s retaining channel and was going to come out at any moment while in operation!You lose control of the steering at any moment!!! The manufacturer even stated that the truck driver loading it was in danger let alone the men using it and of all places to be put in a refinery is nuts! -JLG
This is just the tip of the iceberg of what i blew the whistle on and yes i warned them for quite sometime before i made that call.
Here is another point of what money can buy your way out of like the CEO of Trico Lift Kenny Pisitizzi did where an OSHA area director risked his career to provide me inside OSHA documentation because he knew that Trico Lift Lied to their investigators and he even helped me expose this crime of lying to federal investigators and yes it worked perfectly! Did our government step up?of course not! When that area director provided that documentation it was like a scene out of a movie like the insider i kid you not!
There were even 2 more coworkers who steped forward and lost their jobs.Too much to list here about our case but there is no justice for the little guy anymore.Trico Lift lied to U.S Federal investigators and they were allowed to walk away,Here i am losing everything i worked for my whole life for doing the right thing.
Gregg S
PROUD NAVY DAD
Just one note on that machine that Trico Lift knowingly sent out on rent unsafe on 4/20/09 if i had missed that steering cylinder problem during the safety inspection i was conducting on it i would have been fired on the f’n spot!!!!!!

Obama give BP (and all of the other oil companies) a free pass to make the Gulf their own private cesspool.

$4.5 billion fine to be paid over 6 years for a company with annual revenues of $375 billion, profits of $25 billion and pays no corporate taxes…

after reneging on their original $20 billion “fund” for reparations (which never actually existed), after the irreparable damage done to the food chain in the Gulf, after the thousands of Gulf residents who have contracted all sorts of cancer and diseases from being subjected to the petrochemicals in their water and air and beaches.

Interesting that he reached this agreement one week AFTER his election, because if he had reached it before the election there would have been an outcry.

This is Obama’s first signal that the next four years are going to be 100% service to the 1%. No Rethuglican could have gotten away with this, but Obama supporters call it an ‘historic settlement.’ Pathetic.

This is a travesty of justice! Little different from the officer hung out for the Mei Lai massacre! No high ranking staff held accountable and speaking of accountability,who is watching the disbursement of the monies supposedly put forth by BP to reiomburse those who lost their livelyhood supposedly administered by the same attourney that oversaw the 9/11 fund and how much is he getting?

Good points those. It’s a slap on the corporate wrist, and I would bet those guys taking the fall are getting free legal services and are set for life, financially.
I want you to know I’m in no way connected to Greg Palast, but he is the preeminent journalist in this field. If you have not read his book you are not fully informed.

Mike W: Which Palast book is best, or speaks most directly to this issue in your opinion?

Jerry Lee Mayeux

Nov. 28, 2012, 5:05 p.m.

Consider the connection to;
Environmental Communications CTC1 [KNOWLEDGE]
The more KNOWLEDGE we have the more connections we make.
[ CONSUMERS BE AWARE OF GREENWASHING COMMERCIALS]

its been awhile since i have been on here and the H&H WILDLIFE RESCUE has FILED the MIGRATORY BIRD TREATY ACT criminal CHARGES on BP OIL & TRI STATE BIRD RESCUE

sad day when BP OIL inc. HIRED a ILLEGAL TRI STATE BIRD RESCUE to do the WILDLIFE RESCUE of the oil spill, they show how they still kept VIOLATING FEDERAL REGULATIONS even after the SPILL, and thats the TOP CEO & BOARD MEMBERS , i have their LICENSE , PROPUBLICA if ya want info email me i will give you the INFO to do a story on it

the next CRIMINAL FAZE will start in FEB of 2013 against the TOP CEO"S of BP OIL inc.