Does Palin Really ‘Command’ Alaska’s National Guard?

The McCain campaign has made much of Gov. Sarah Palin’s role as commander in chief of the Alaska National Guard.
A spokesman claimed, now infamously, that “any decision that she has made as the commander of the National Guard that’s deployed overseas, is more of a decision than Barack Obama has been making as he’s been running for president.”
The Alaska National Guard has served in a number of military operations overseas. They were deployed alongside Mongolian troops in Iraq, and worked at the Bagram Airbase in Afghanistan. They have also trained with Japanese troops in a program called North Wind 2008, and participated in the humanitarian Operation Pacific Angel in Cambodia.
But as a number of news organizations have pointed out, Palin was not in command of any of those operations.
So what exact role do governors play in overseeing National Guard units? And what incidents has the Alaska National Guard responded to while Palin has been in charge?
The president commands National Guard troops whenever they’re deployed in federal missions, such as the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan. State governors only command the guardsmen in operations inside their states, traditionally in response to disasters like floods and fires.
According to Alaska National Guard spokeswoman, Kalei Brooks, in the two years of Palin’s term, the National Guard has run 521 missions and saved 200 lives.
Major tasks, Brooks said, have been fighting wildfires and providing standby security during two meetings, including the International Whaling Commission (PDF) meeting in May 2007.
But even in state operations, Palin has a limited role. For big or unusual events, Palin authorizes the National Guard’s actions, but for most run-of-the-mill work, Palin isn’t involved at all.
Brooks explained that the National Guard works with other state security and emergency services, which each cover different geographical areas of the huge state. Each agency has a set of agreements that authorize them to respond automatically in an emergency, without needing the governor’s specific authorization every time hunters get stranded in swamps, or Swedish tourists get stuck in the snow (PDF).
And while McCain spokesman Tucker Bound was correct when he told CNN that Palin, “makes the decision as to how to equip, how to command the National Guard in Alaska,” the federal government, not the state, provides all of their equipment and material.
Brooks said the governor nevertheless plays an important role in managing the 3,850 Alaskan guardsmen. “Just because she’s not in command, doesn’t mean she’s not involved,” she said.
For instance, when Palin visited Alaskan guardsmen in Kuwait in July 2007 she asked about how their families were coping back home, according to Brooks.
“One of the things that came up was that a lot of these soldiers were from rural areas where subsistence hunting and fishing is very common,” said Brooks. With their “primary hunter and gatherer” deployed in the Mideast, said Brooks, some families were going hungry. She added that common prey includes moose and caribou.
Palin arranged for exceptions to Alaska’s laws on subsistence hunting licenses so that families “could have people hunt and gather for them while their husbands were away.”
Get Updates
Our Hottest Stories
- Donations to Scott Walker Flagged as Potential Fraud
- In Race For Better Cell Service, Men Who Climb Towers Pay With Their Lives
- Billion Dollar Bait & Switch: States Divert Foreclosure Deal Funds
- Pardon Attorney Torpedoes Plea for Presidential Mercy
- Patient Died at New York VA Hospital After Alarm Was Ignored
- Introducing the ProPublica Patient Harm Community on Facebook
- Built for a Simpler Era, OSHA Struggles When Tower Climbers Die
- Got Student Loans? Share Your Documents With Us
- Remember Stuxnet? Why the U.S. is Still Vulnerable
- Congressional Leader Calls for Investigation of the Pardon Office
- Donations to Scott Walker Flagged as Potential Fraud
- Pardon Attorney Torpedoes Plea for Presidential Mercy
- Air Force Pilots Balk at Flying the World’s Most Expensive Fighter Jet
- In Race For Better Cell Service, Men Who Climb Towers Pay With Their Lives
- Patient Died at New York VA Hospital After Alarm Was Ignored
- Watchdog Group Calls for Probe of Lobbyists Behind Congressional Trip to Taiwan
- Billion Dollar Bait & Switch: States Divert Foreclosure Deal Funds
- N.Y. Congressman Will Reimburse Costs for $22,000 Taiwan trip
- Happy Graduation! Here's The Best, Most Depressing Journalism on Student Debt
- Remember Stuxnet? Why the U.S. is Still Vulnerable







2 comments
Don
Sept. 4, 2008, 7:18 a.m.
The assumptions behind this article reveal your liberal bias.
First, if there are no disasters, a governor will not need to order the National Guard to do anything. This is a good thing. If things are routine, a governor will not become personally involved in any of the many state departments.
Second, former Governor Kathleen Blanco of Louisiana, a Democrat, DID face a natural disaster called Hurricane Katrina, but did not order the National Guard to do anything. I do not recall any headlines “Blanco Fails to Order Louisiana National Guard to Help New Orleans”. Instead, the liberal media blamed everything on Bush even though local and state officials have the primary responsibility to deal with natural disasters.
Don W. Joe
Asian American Politics
http://www.asianam.org
TJ Sexton
Sept. 9, 2008, 2:42 p.m.
First: This isn’t about what governor did what and news organization did or did not print that information. This is an article about Governor Palin’s stated qualifications to be the Commander-in-Chief of the world’s largest military force in active deployment across the globe.
She has stated that her qualifications include a) She commands the Alaska National Guard and b) her son is in military and will soon deploy to Iraq.
Anyone who has been in the military knows there is a distinct difference between being in command of a unit and the job that Governor Palin, or any Governor for that matter, holds. In fact, I don’t think you really need to have military experience to make this distinction. The President has the ultimate power to instantly commit the armed forces of the US, to combat, anywhere in the world. While Search and Rescue operations are extremely important and place lives on the line; are we really talking ‘apples and apples’?
The second qualification, while admirable for the Palin family and appreciated by a grateful nation, does not qualify one to command the Free World. Being the mother of a soldier makes the governor eminently qualified to be the ‘mother of a soldier’. I applaud her support, if more politicians had children in the ‘line of fire’ maybe there would be less fire.
And while the accusation against Governor Blanco has absolutely nothing to do with Governor Palin, it has been argued that it’s not true. As I understand it; on August 26, Governor Blanco declared a ‘State of Emergency’ and on 27 August she requested that President Bush declare an emergency for the State of Louisiana due to Hurricane Katrina. On that day, 27 August, the White House responded.
Thomas Sexton
Commenting on this story is closed.