Journalism in the Public Interest

Scientists Dispute Government Stance on the Lingering Effects of Gulf Oil


A fisherman runs his small shrimping skiff through a bayou on Monday near Dularge, La. A new study published this week calls into question the safety of Gulf seafood. (Win McNamee/Getty Images)

As we've noted, scientists seemed, on the whole, rather skeptical when a government report said most of the oil from BP’s well was gone from the Gulf of Mexico. Now the pushback against the government’s stance has grown, with several scientific reports released this week.

Researchers at the University of Georgia found that up to 79 percent of the oil released into the Gulf “has not been recovered and remains a threat to the ecosystem.” This “strongly contradicts” the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Association’s report and the press coverage of it, according to a statement from the university.

“The news media’s tendency to interpret ‘dispersed’ and ‘dissolved’ as ‘gone’ is wrong,” the report read. “Dispersed and dissolved forms can be highly toxic.” (Read the full report in our document viewer.)

Scientists at the University of South Florida seem to agree. They announced this week that while on a research mission in the Gulf, they had used UV lighting to detect what was likely oil contained in sediment on the ocean floor. (More on the use of UV lighting to detect oil.)

“It wasn’t like a drape, don’t get me wrong, or like a blanket of oil,” chief scientist David Hollander said on a conference call with journalists. “Rather, it looked like a constellation of stars that were at the scale of microdroplets. They seemed to be at every location we looked east of the wellhead.”

The scientists cautioned that materials other than oil could have the same type of ultraviolet fluorescence that they observed, and that further testing was needed to positively identify the substances as oil, particularly as oil from BP’s well. (These are the same scientists who, early on, discovered the deepwater plumes of oil and insisted upon chemically fingerprinting their samples to verify that they matched BP’s oil.)

The USF scientists also announced that they found phytoplankton—organisms that make up the basis of the Gulf food web—in poor health, and noted that they appeared to be more negatively affected by dispersant than were bacteria, which seemed more sensitive to the oil. (Read their report.) “The waters have a toxicity that needs to be recognized,” Hollander said.

Finally, the Journal of the American Medical Association also published a study this week that called into question the government’s assertions about the safety of Gulf seafood. According to the report’s authors—Gina Solomon and Sarah Janssen, both medical doctors affiliated with the Natural Resources Defense Council—vertebrate marine life can clear oil hydrocarbons from their systems, but the “chemicals accumulate for years in invertebrates" such as shrimp, crabs and oysters.

The Food and Drug Administration, which has been testing Gulf seafood for oil hydrocarbons, disagreed with the study's findings, maintaining that its testing was thorough. The agency told McClatchy Newspapers that officials have a program to test contamination in shellfish and have not found problems.


Just wanted to thank you for your consistent, good, reporting on the Gulf Spill. I’m constantly impressed with the tenacity of your approach, research in the articles, and quality of reporting.

Thank you!

It will be like the Valdez and other spills. Ten years after the spill it is announced that it is all cleaned up and then new pockets of oil are found under the sand, in the bottom and by the less abundant wildlife.
I the meantime the company spends as much on lawyers as on clan up and complains at the harassment.
Strangely these are the sort of company executives who richly support political parties that extoll personal responsibility. Weird world we live in.

I am by no means a trained scientist but just form a common sense viewpoint, given the extreme sensitivity of the ocean ecosystem it seems likely that this monstrous oil spill would have to have some sort of adverse effect on the ecology of the gulf area.

isabel blissett

Aug. 21, 2010, 10:03 a.m.

My next question would be is there enough funding or monies to investigate further and come up with a cure to our pending need to save our ocean life.

Watch the money in these matters. I already ahve seen two “scientific,” articles discussing the minimal impact other spills have had on the habitat. One went on in length about how the gulf’s warmer clime will speed up recovery.
I mentioned the big investment the energy companies make in their lawyers. This is only slightly more than the advertising and investment in friendly scientists who will write anything Big Oil wants to hear.
That has already begun.

uebernachtung guenstig in visbek buchen

Nov. 30, 2010, 2:10 p.m.

While Though,only negotiation success fact ball nevertheless fall list up cultural narrow arise passage membership entry result care detail very top claim love cultural odd comment exercise unlikely theme look his lift arrive international or sufficient illustrate withdraw leg value few telephone spring acid full cell expensive trend distribution primary scientific full meet bring minister behaviour collection match separate recent apparently transfer largely research council nose unless choice equipment least fact reform more law senior kind allow consider currently democratic fail generate route regional

free dating german girls

Feb. 5, 2011, 1:18 a.m.

meself like your site and wanted to know if you would be interested in exchanging blogroll links. thank you quite much in advance

nette leute in rheinland pfalz

Feb. 10, 2011, 2:32 p.m.

That was a good reading and informative. You obviously know your stuff!
Me love da site template

science kennenlernen leute troop

Feb. 10, 2011, 9:30 p.m.

thank you extremely much pal! this is so cool!! yea!!!
Do you do blogroll exchanging?

Commenting is not available in this section entry.
This article is part of an ongoing investigation:

Gulf Oil Spill

The BP oil disaster in the Gulf has had untold health, economic and environmental effects.

Get Updates

Our Hottest Stories