Parsing Presidential Pardons
President George W. Bush decided 1,918 pardon requests during his two terms in office and stuck largely to recommendations from the Office of the Pardon Attorney. ProPublica analyzed 494 randomly selected cases and to find characteristics associated with getting a pardon. The results:
Race of petitioner
Whites were more likely to receive a pardon than minorities.
- Non-Hispanic White
- Native American
Notes: Because there are so few Asian and African Americans in the sample, this result is not statistically significant. Although President Bush pardoned seven African Americans, none was in our sample. The projected pardon rate for blacks is between 2 and 4 percent assuming the sample reflects the actual proportion of African Americans in the cases Bush decided. ProPublica was unable to determine the race of 20 individuals who were denied pardons.
Married individuals were more likely to receive a pardon than singles.
- Not Married
Pardons by type of crime.
- Financial crime
- Violent crime
Note: Individuals may have committed multiple crimes or have offenses in multiple categories.
People who served prison time were less likely to be pardoned.
- Probation Only
Note: Other sentences included fines and discharges from the military.
Years since sentencing
People with older offenses were more likely to be pardoned.
- 20+ Years
- 10 to 19 Years
- Fewer than 10 Years
Subsequent crime found for petitioner
Those with a subsequent crime were less likely to be pardoned.
- No subsequent crime found
- Subsequent crime
Note: Although ProPublica attempted a complete background check, it is possible that some petitioners had committed crimes that were too old to be in electronic databases, had records expunged or committed crimes in areas where there is no public access to criminal records.
People with a bankruptcy or lien were less likely to be pardoned.
People were more likely to get a pardon of a member of Congress wrote to the pardon office.
- No correspondence
White criminals seeking presidential pardons are nearly four times as likely to succeed as people of color, a ProPublica examination has found.
Latest Stories in this Project
- Three Things Obama's New Clemency Initiative Doesn't Do
- President Obama Tells Clarence Aaron He Can Finally Go Home
- The Sweeping Presidential Power to Help Prisoners That Holder Didn’t Mention
- Clarence Aaron Still Waiting for Clemency, Months after Report Found Pardon Atty Misrepresented Case
- Despite New Pardons, Obama’s Clemency Rate is Still Lowest in Recent History