Lucky Man: CEO’s Repeated Good Fortune in Timing Stock Sales
Note: The Trade is not subject to our Creative Commons license.
This is the story of a company and its fortunate chief executive.
Questcor Pharmaceuticals is a biotechnology company with a $4 billion market capitalization. Good things keep happening to Questcor in the middle of the month. Here’s what’s notable: The middle of the month just happens to be the time that the company’s chief executive, Don M. Bailey, sells stock through his regular selling plan.
To understand what seems to be going on here, a little context is in order. Many company executives adopt trading plans through which they arrange to sell stock on specific dates or at specific prices. The underlying idea of these plans is that because the selling is automatic, executives avoid any appearance that they are trading on inside information.
I contacted the company to ask about Mr. Bailey’s sales and the timing of its announcements. A company spokeswoman confirmed by email that he had a regular selling plan. She wrote that the chief executive’s plan was adopted in 2011 “as part of a normal financial diversification strategy.” His plan calls for sales at monthly intervals and has been renewed each year since.
“There have been no changes to any plans since their adoption, and there have been no sales by Don outside of the plan since its adoption,” she wrote. The company did not respond further to an email and a call, did not respond to my request to interview Mr. Bailey or any other executive, and did not comment on the timing of its public disclosures.
Questcor’s rise has been remarkable. The company sells an anti-inflammatory drug called Acthar, developed in the early 1950s and extracted from pig pituitary glands. Questcor bought the drug for a mere $100,000 in 2001 and then increases the selling price by orders of magnitude. The price of a five-milliliter vial jumped to $28,000 from $50.
Today, a full course of the drug can cost more than $100,000. The company has acknowledged its business and marketing practices have fallen under federal scrutiny. The drug was being used to treat a rare condition that afflicts hundreds of infants a year, but Questcor vastly increased sales by marketing it to multiple sclerosis patients and for adults suffering from nephrotic syndrome and rheumatologic conditions.
The company’s explosive growth is “a story for these troubled times in American health care — a tale of aggressive marketing, questionable medicine and, not least, out-of-control costs,” as Andrew Pollack of The New York Times wrote in a December 2012 article.
The controversies have drawn short-sellers and skeptical media attention. But so far, the critics have been wrong at least on the company’s stock, which, while slightly off its 52-week high, still trades at $69.28 a share.
By my count, positive news has struck Questcor mid-month at least six times over the last ten months. Clearly, the timing of the news announcements might be coincidental and these weren’t the only pieces of good news for the company in that time. Securities law requires companies to put out news, good or bad, as soon as they know it. But the timing on some of the announcements raises questions.
Here are the news items, in order of how fortunate their timing was for Mr. Bailey’s stock sales:
OCT. 10, 2013 Questcor disclosed its cash balances in a securities filing. Doing a bit of math, as they tend to do, Wall Street analysts and investors figured out that this meant the third quarter was stronger than expected and would top analyst estimates. “We now expect a sizable 3Q beat and would be buying the stock ahead of earnings,” analysts at Oppenheimer wrote. On Oct. 9, the stock closed at $54.60 a share. The next day, it shot up to $59.62 a share and kept rising.
Four days later, Mr. Bailey sold 40,000 shares, most at $62 and more than $63 a share, highs for that month to that point.
At the end of the month, the company revealed in a post-earnings conference call that the United States attorney in Manhattan and the Securities and Exchange Commission had joined an investigation by the United States attorney in Philadelphia into the company’s marketing and business practices. The stock tumbled 14 percent, to $60.01 from $69.73.
DEC. 11, 2013 Questcor formed some new board committees, and issued a filing with the S.E.C. that disclosed this development. The company said one of panels was a “strategic advisory committee” that would address a “persistent and significant discount in the company’s valuation relative to its peer companies.” The words “strategic advisory” are a dog whistle for Wall Street, signaling that the company is exploring doing a transaction, such as selling itself, to increase the stock. No dummies, investors reacted positively and the stock moved higher.
Two days later, Mr. Bailey sold 40,000 shares, mostly at $53.30 a share. The stock had been falling that month, and was at $51.69 on Dec 9.
MAY 14, 2013 Questcor filed an 8K that included a presentation the company delivered at a Bank of America conference that same day. The stock moved up to the highs for the month, to close at $42.40 from $37.50 the day before. Mr. Bailey sold 20,000 shares at $36.70 on May 13. The next day, he sold 160,000, all at prices at least $40.40 a share. Just a week earlier, the stock had closed at $33.58. The total 180,000 shares sold was far more than his usual sale of 40,000 shares a month.
JAN. 13, 2014 The company filed its presentation to be made at the JPMorgan Chase conference, with positive earnings news and a reiteration of its exploration of stock-goosing transactions. In contrast with its presentation for the Bank of America conference, the company filed three days before the event. That very day, Mr. Bailey sold 40,000 shares at more than $53 a share.
A few days before the company made its filing, the stock had traded at its low for the month, closing at $50.19 on Jan. 9.
NOV. 12, 2013 The company announced that G. Kelly Martin, the chief executive of the Irish drugmaker Elan, would join the board. The stock moved higher. On Nov. 13, the stock traded right around the highs for the month. And that day, Mr. Bailey sold his regular 40,000 shares.
JUNE 11, 2013 The company announced it was purchasing Synacthen from Novartis. This was good news, because Synacthen is similar to Questcor’s drug. The company was taking out a competitor. The stock rose 15 percent that day. On June 13, Mr. Bailey sold his 40,000 shares, near recent highs.
Questcor may just be an extreme example of what’s going on regularly in corporate America. Questcor has a big stock buyback program, as insiders regularly dump stock. In these heady days of market highs, most big companies are racing to buy back their stock while insiders are unloading. The companies of the Standard & Poor’s 500-stock index bought $459 billion worth of stock last year, according to Thomson Reuters, which also calculated that those corporations’ insiders sold $32.7 billion in the 12 months to mid-February.
As The Wall Street Journal explained in a 2012 series of articles, selling plans are hard for investors, regulators and the public to track. Companies and executives don’t have to disclose their arrangements to any federal agency. The companies can alter and change them without notifying the public.
Oh, and the executives can still trade in the company’s stock at other times not mentioned in the selling plans.
The Questcor situation adds another potential vulnerability to the list: Put out good news and then sell as the world buys.
About The Trade
Recent Stories by Jesse Eisinger
- The Fed Hates To Burst Your Bubble
- The Sorry State of Bank Apologies
- Big Investors Push for Auditors to Sign Financial Statements
- Mary Jo White was Supposed to Turn Around the S.E.C. She Hasn’t.
- Does Valeant’s Cost-Cutting Go Too Far?
- BlackRock Doesn’t Need A Scarlet Letter
- The Justice Department’s Foreign Aggression